Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-04 Thread Doyle Saylor
Greetings Economists, On Aug 4, 2007, at 9:48 AM, Ted Winslow wrote: Balzac, for instance, who is represented as someone "who so thoroughly studied every shade of avarice," is cited as insightful about the different roles played by "hoarding" in "childhood" and mature forms of avarice; he "repre

Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-04 Thread Ted Winslow
On 4-Aug-07, at 10:27 AM, Doyle Saylor wrote: Greetings Economists, On Aug 4, 2007, at 6:08 AM, Ted Winslow wrote: How can econometric methods be used to test whether this treatment of capitalist individuality and its historical development is realistic? Doyle; Well graph theory (see Erdos)

Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-04 Thread Doyle Saylor
Greetings Economists, On Aug 4, 2007, at 6:08 AM, Ted Winslow wrote: How can econometric methods be used to test whether this treatment of capitalist individuality and its historical development is realistic? Doyle; Well graph theory (see Erdos) is amendable to metrics. Further if you referen

Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-04 Thread Ted Winslow
Gil Skillman wrote: all of applied (at least micro) mainstream economics,which is pretty much entirely based on methodological individualism, and which routinely and massively yields testable predictions that are then brought to the data via more or less rigorous econometric tests. Of course th

Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-03 Thread Jim Devine
thanks, Gil. On 8/3/07, Gil Skillman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I'm reposting this, hoping for an answer. In economics, what uses does > > methodological individualism have in the actual attempt to understand > > the world (that is, beyond mere ideology)? I can think of two so far: > > > > 1)

Re: [PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-03 Thread Gil Skillman
> I'm reposting this, hoping for an answer. In economics, what uses does > methodological individualism have in the actual attempt to understand > the world (that is, beyond mere ideology)? I can think of two so far: > > 1) the free rider or collective action problem: it's really hard for a > group

[PEN-L] Jim's reposting

2007-08-03 Thread ann li
Subject: query: methodological individualism OK, here's my take on this: Other than appealing to the more canonical methods that heterodox econ addresses, I would suggest that Lawson's approach to "empirical and underlying social ontology" would suggest that we can still use some ( not all ) for