Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-24 Thread rfisk
Sad. I think this is a cultural issue which is mitigated in most professional organizations when agile is adopted. In my experience, waterfall pits testers against developers. In an agile environment that demarcation is blurred. If I'm reading that report properly it appears as if the top of

Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread Andy Lester
On Oct 23, 2008, at 12:37 PM, chromatic wrote: I don't care about backchannel communication between other authors and CPAN Testers, but how can you blame Shlomi for thinking that public humiliation isn't a vital component of Kwalitee? There's prior art:

Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread Yitzchak Scott-Thoennes
On Thu, October 23, 2008 10:37 am, chromatic wrote: I don't care about backchannel communication between other authors and CPAN Testers, but how can you blame Shlomi for thinking that public humiliation isn't a vital component of Kwalitee? There's prior art:

Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread chromatic
On Thursday 23 October 2008 06:34:41 Ovid wrote: That being said, why are you trying to publicly humiliate people by sending this information to Perl-QA? I've contacted Perl-QA to try and find a smoke author before, but not to name and shame. That just seems rude. I don't care about

Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread Andy Lester
On Oct 23, 2008, at 1:25 PM, Yitzchak Scott-Thoennes wrote: http://cpants.perl.org/highscores/hall_of_shame That looks sorted by kwalitee and author. If we're shaming people, author name shouldn't be a factor. Could it be by kwalitee and most recent release date instead? How about

Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread chromatic
On Thursday 23 October 2008 11:25:05 Yitzchak Scott-Thoennes wrote: On Thu, October 23, 2008 10:37 am, chromatic wrote: I don't care about backchannel communication between other authors and CPAN Testers, but how can you blame Shlomi for thinking that public humiliation isn't a vital

Re: Public Humiliation and Kwalitee (was Re: Tested File-Find-Object-0.1.1 with Class::Accessor not installed)

2008-10-23 Thread Gabor Szabo
http://cpants.perl.org/highscores/hall_of_shame It says Not Found thanks domm Gabor