Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-08 Thread Igal Sapir
Brent, On Tue, May 7, 2019 at 12:42 PM Brent Wood wrote: > I have not used SS for spatial data, but I don't have a Postgres database > without Postgis installed. The OSGEO ecosystem and synergies with other > FOSS GIS tools is fantastic. > > And it does not stop with the Postgis extension. For t

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-07 Thread Brent Wood
I have not used SS for spatial data, but I don't have a Postgres database without Postgis installed. The OSGEO ecosystem and synergies with other FOSS GIS tools is fantastic. And it does not stop with the Postgis extension. For time series data (anything from fleet management to sensor data) Po

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-07 Thread Steven Lembark
> Next month I'll be making a presentation about Postgres to a SQL > Server crowd in L.A. at their SQL Saturday event. > > I was wondering if anyone has any tips that are specific for SQL > Server users? Best features? Known issues? Common rebuttals? PosgreSQL is more than a "database", it's

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Thomas Kellerer
Igal Sapir schrieb am 07.05.2019 um 07:58: > GIS is a good feature but it's a niche feature, so while I'll mention > it with extensions I am looking for more general-purpose comparisons > and areas where Postgres is as-good or better than SQL Server. I have a comparison of various DBMS products on

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Tony Shelver
For me, another very useful featureset in Postgres is the extensive set of datatypes and functions, including the strong JSONB support. Also, i would focus on the widespread support of Postgresql by services such as Amazon, Google, Heroku, Another place to focus on would be the really extensive l

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Igal Sapir
Tony, On Mon, May 6, 2019 at 10:35 PM Tony Shelver wrote: > I have to agree on the geospatial (GIS) features. > I converted from SQL Server to Postgresql for our extended tracking > database. The SS geospatial feature set doesn't seem nearly as robust or > complete or perfoirmant as that suppli

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Igal Sapir
Ron, On Mon, May 6, 2019 at 12:54 PM Ron wrote: > On 5/6/19 2:47 PM, Igal Sapir wrote: > > but I want to instill confidence in them that anything they do with SQL > > Server can be done with Postgres. > > Right off the top of my head, here are some things you can't (easily and > trivially) do in

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Igal Sapir
Brent, On Mon, May 6, 2019 at 1:44 PM Brent Wood wrote: > Hi Igal, > > One relevant comment I found interesting a couple of years ago... > > A New Zealand Govt agency was installing an institutional GIS system > (several thousand potential users). It supported different back-end spatial > databa

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Tony Shelver
I have to agree on the geospatial (GIS) features. I converted from SQL Server to Postgresql for our extended tracking database. The SS geospatial feature set doesn't seem nearly as robust or complete or perfoirmant as that supplied by PostGIS. The PostGIS ecosystem of open source / 3rd party tools

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Michel Pelletier
On Mon, May 6, 2019 at 2:49 PM Adam Brusselback wrote: > I think the main "gotcha" when I moved from SQL Server to Postgres was I > didn't even realize the amount of in-line t-sql I would use to just get > stuff done for ad-hoc analysis. Postgres doesn't have a good way to emulate > this. DO bloc

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Thomas Kellerer
Ravi Krishna schrieb am 06.05.2019 um 23:56: I recently had to write an equivalent of UNPIVOT. UNPIVOT is actually quite easy with Postgres: https://blog.sql-workbench.eu/post/unpivot-with-postgres/ Thomas

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Ravi Krishna
> I think the main "gotcha" when I moved from SQL Server to Postgres was > I didn't even realize the amount of in-line t-sql I would use to just get > stuff done > for ad-hoc analysis. T-SQL is an exceptionally powerful SQL based language. Add to it, the many functions SS has. I recently had

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Adam Brusselback
I think the main "gotcha" when I moved from SQL Server to Postgres was I didn't even realize the amount of in-line t-sql I would use to just get stuff done for ad-hoc analysis. Postgres doesn't have a good way to emulate this. DO blocks cannot return resultsets, so short of creating a function and

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Ravi Krishna
more: 1. No db level backup/restore in PG, at least no easy way. 2. No cross db query.

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Brent Wood
Hi Igal, One relevant comment I found interesting a couple of years ago... A New Zealand Govt agency was installing an institutional GIS system (several thousand potential users). It supported different back-end spatial databases. Previous installs of this system for other clients had used MS S

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Ron
On 5/6/19 2:47 PM, Igal Sapir wrote: but I want to instill confidence in them that anything they do with SQL Server can be done with Postgres. Right off the top of my head, here are some things you can't (easily and trivially) do in Postgres: - Transparent Data Encryption - Block level full,

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Igal Sapir
Ravi, On Mon, May 6, 2019 at 12:28 PM Ravi Krishna wrote: > > I was wondering if anyone has any tips that are specific for SQL Server > users? Best features? Known issues? Common rebuttals? > > Are you talking about SS to PG migration. > > Generally SQLServer shops use SS specific functions a

Re: Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Ravi Krishna
> I was wondering if anyone has any tips that are specific for SQL Server > users?  Best features?  Known issues?  Common rebuttals? Are you talking about SS to PG migration. Generally SQLServer shops use SS specific functions and T-SQL heavily since they provide very good functionality. For e

Postgres for SQL Server users

2019-05-06 Thread Igal Sapir
Next month I'll be making a presentation about Postgres to a SQL Server crowd in L.A. at their SQL Saturday event. I was wondering if anyone has any tips that are specific for SQL Server users? Best features? Known issues? Common rebuttals? Thanks, Igal