RE: Upgrade procedure

2019-11-05 Thread Kevin Brannen
>> For us, we always use pg_upgrade even for minor updates because it >> feels safer to me. That being said, we rarely do minor updates and >> just do majors because upgrading is just hard enough (lots of >> testing!) we tend to wait and then jump further. Upgrading is known to >> take a maintenanc

Re: Upgrade procedure

2019-11-05 Thread rihad
On 11/05/2019 10:05 PM, Kevin Brannen wrote: From: rihad Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, then start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the package in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow modification of currently running binar

RE: Upgrade procedure

2019-11-05 Thread Rich Shepard
On Tue, 5 Nov 2019, Kevin Brannen wrote: The manual or others here are more knowledgeable than I, but I believe that for a "minor" upgrade, you can just swap out the code and restart PG. For major upgrades, the PG server is going to have to come down as the underlying files might be changed/tran

RE: Upgrade procedure

2019-11-05 Thread Kevin Brannen
>> >From: rihad >> >>> Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, >>> then start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the >>> package in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow >>> modification of currently running binaries, which is most Unix

Re: Upgrade procedure

2019-10-30 Thread rihad
>From: rihad Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, then start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the package in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow modification of currently running binaries, which is most Unix OS, M$ Windows b

RE: Upgrade procedure

2019-10-30 Thread Kevin Brannen
>From: rihad >Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, then >start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the package >in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow modification of currently >running binaries, which is most Unix OS, M$ Windows

Re: Upgrade procedure

2019-10-30 Thread Francisco Olarte
On Wed, Oct 30, 2019 at 6:00 PM rihad wrote: > Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, > then start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the > package in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow > modification of currently running binaries, w

Upgrade procedure

2019-10-30 Thread rihad
Hi, all. Why is it normally suggested to stop the server, upgrade it, then start it? Wouldn't it be easier & quicker to simply upgrade the package in-place and restart the service? On OSen that allow modification of currently running binaries, which is most Unix OS, M$ Windows being a notable e