[CC Request For Nomination] Steve Winter

2016-12-01 Thread Steve Winter
Good morning everyone I’m writing to the list to express my interest in being nominated as a member of the FIG Core Committee. I’m seeking a nomination in this way as I have no strong affiliation with any of the Member Projects. Allow me to introduce myself. Originally from New Zealand I’v

Re: [REVIEW] PSR-16 Simple Cache

2016-12-01 Thread Josh Di Fabio
Thanks for the reply, Rasmus. In principle I think we want the same things. However, I think the wording in the spec is wrong, especially this part: "Different CacheInterface instances ... MUST be logically independent." Do you agree that the above clause from the spec makes the following class i

Re: [REVIEW] PSR-16 Simple Cache

2016-12-01 Thread Rasmus Schultz
> why are we talking about pools in a spec which deliberately doesn't define them? It's out of scope. I'd say it's the other way around - the PSR-16 cache-abstraction represents a logical collection. The definition, in my opinion, is perfect - if we don't define what it is, people might assume th

Re: [REVIEW] PSR-16 Simple Cache

2016-12-01 Thread Josh Di Fabio
> If the pools aren't logically independent, their namespaces end up colliding. They need to be logically distinct, even if they are on the same physical server. This is an application concern. It's the responsibility of the application to provide CacheInterface instances which are usable and corr

Re: [REVIEW] PSR-16 Simple Cache

2016-12-01 Thread Larry Garfield
On Thu, Dec 1, 2016, at 03:24 AM, Josh Di Fabio wrote: > > Different CacheInterface instances MAY be backed by the same datastore, *but > MUST be logically independent.* > > The second clause seems to be needlessly restrictive and appears to be > incompatible with decorators. What is the purpose o

Re: [PSR-12] Survey for outstanding issues

2016-12-01 Thread Amo Chohan
Hi all, This might not be the correct place to post this (please point me in the right direction if, that's the case) but I have some thoughts on the topic of blank lines after the opening From what I can see, there's some inconsistency in having a blank line after the opening tag. The examples

Re: [REVIEW] PSR-16 Simple Cache

2016-12-01 Thread Josh Di Fabio
> Different CacheInterface instances MAY be backed by the same datastore, *but MUST be logically independent.* The second clause seems to be needlessly restrictive and appears to be incompatible with decorators. What is the purpose of this clause? On Wed, Nov 30, 2016 at 4:10 PM Larry Garfield w