Re: [WG][VOTE] PSR-17 Review

2018-05-17 Thread Glenn Eggleton
ditor) > - myself (Sponsor) > - Stefano Torresi > - Matthieu Napoli > - Korvin Szanto > - Glenn Eggleton > - Oscar Otero > - Tobias Nyholm > > The by-laws do not stipulate a time-frame for how long the vote must > run, though 2 weeks is the standard period. As suc

Re: [WG][VOTE] PSR-15 Review

2017-11-30 Thread Glenn Eggleton
tthew Weier O'Phinney (Sponsor) > - Stefano Torresi > - Matthieu Napoli > - Korvin Szanto > - Glenn Eggleton > - Oscar Otero > > The by-laws do not stipulate a time-frame for how long the vote must > run. As such, I will set a maximum time-frame of 1 week, and cl

Re: [Internals] [FIG 3.0 Transition] Core Committee Nominations Open

2016-11-07 Thread Glenn Eggleton
Hi Adam, It looks like it's power creep from FIG 3.0. https://github.com/php-fig/fig-standards/pull/752/files#diff-7aeee0a55f5e81ea8a0b5f9dc76c6822R19 Cheers On Saturday, November 5, 2016 at 8:45:49 AM UTC-4, Adam Culp wrote: > > Sorry, and I hope I'm not beating a dead horse, but when did the

Re: [PSR-11] Remove ContainerException

2016-08-15 Thread Glenn Eggleton
I believe removal of it is going to cause a lot of BC Breaks... For example in Slim we do extend from *ContainerException* [1]: https://github.com/slimphp/Slim/blob/3.x/Slim/Exception/ContainerException.php We do actually use it.

Re: [PSR-15] FrameInterface

2016-08-15 Thread Glenn Eggleton
Naming things are hard if and only if their function is hard to define I still don't see any added value in turning the $next into a formal interface. Moving on from that: NextMiddlewareInterface might be okay for a name... NextMiddlewareInterface -> process ( Request ) On Sunday,

Re: Alternative to FIG 3.0 - Is it time to call FIG complete?

2016-08-10 Thread Glenn Eggleton
. I guess this would likely be the focus of the new secretaries. On Tuesday, August 9, 2016 at 5:41:47 PM UTC-4, Phil Sturgeon wrote: > > > > On Tuesday, August 9, 2016 at 4:17:04 PM UTC-4, Glenn Eggleton wrote: >> >> If FIG is the standards body why has the FIG not formally c

Re: Alternative to FIG 3.0 - Is it time to call FIG complete?

2016-08-09 Thread Glenn Eggleton
If FIG is the standards body why has the FIG not formally changed it's name? On Tuesday, August 9, 2016 at 12:54:04 PM UTC-4, Larry Garfield wrote: > > Given that there's ~9 specs being worked on currently in various stages, > the idea that FIG's work is "done" seems completely unsupportable. >

Re: Alternative to FIG 3.0: Encourage *-interop projects

2016-08-09 Thread Glenn Eggleton
100% agree with Gary and Paul. *-interop projects are the embodiment of everything the FIG wishes to achieve, "Framework INTEROPERABILTY group". Can this be done in the purposed "Working Groups of FIG 3.0" ? I do not think so. >From the TLDR of FIG 3.0, context of talking about the Working

Re: [PSR-15] FrameInterface

2016-07-29 Thread Glenn Eggleton
+1 On Friday, July 29, 2016 at 10:15:30 AM UTC-4, Matthieu Napoli wrote: > > Thanks Woody and Andrew for your answers, > > Type safety is a valid point. I'm all for type safety, however in this > case I'm not convinced it's worth it since it's just a callable that takes > a request and returns

Re: [PSR-15] FrameInterface

2016-07-29 Thread Glenn Eggleton
On Friday, July 29, 2016 at 5:41:07 AM UTC-4, Andrew Carter wrote: > > Type safety, IDE type hinting. > > A callable can be anything, an interface guarantees parameter types and, > in PHP 7, return types. > This dynamic property is an asset, not a liability, which is why there is so much

Re: [Internal] [Discussion] Paul M Jones

2016-07-21 Thread Glenn Eggleton
On Thursday, July 21, 2016 at 7:46:49 AM UTC-4, Anthony Ferrara wrote: > > All, > > * Paul continues to provide his excellent (and observable) technical skills >> > > This has been mentioned over and over again; how Paul has unbelievable > technical skills. May I point out that he hasn't

[PSR-15] Middleware changes?

2016-07-12 Thread Glenn Eggleton
Hello all, I want to try to make a case for some changes on the PSR. I realize it's been through a few iterations, but as a user of psr-7 middleware I don't see myself adopting the current 15 and here's why. 1) $frame I have no idea what $frame represents, I cannot explain it to another

Re: [Internal] [Discussion] Paul M Jones

2016-07-06 Thread Glenn Eggleton
Lukas, I do apologize I see now that I had forgotten some facts in your original post. Paul, thank you for the timeline, it is very informative. While I do feel as if private resolution was attempted, there was not sufficient time given to you to change. Instead you were blind-sided by the

Re: [Internal] [Discussion] Paul M Jones

2016-07-06 Thread Glenn Eggleton
On Wednesday, July 6, 2016 at 1:25:40 PM UTC-4, Larry Garfield wrote: > On 07/05/2016 12:57 PM, Paul Jones wrote: > > Dear Voting Representatives, > > *snip* > > > As such, you can see that the complaint appeals to only one portion of > "the PHP Community" -- perhaps a portion with which the

Re: [Internal] [Discussion] Paul M Jones

2016-07-05 Thread Glenn Eggleton
On Tuesday, July 5, 2016 at 6:53:04 AM UTC-4, Alessandro Lai wrote: > > This discussion will not linger indefinitely, there is a two weeks > expiration date set up, that is approaching. > This expiration did not came out of thin air, is the standard pre-vote > discussion duration here in the