Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread wes
On Tue, Sep 19, 2023 at 2:41 PM John Jason Jordan wrote: > either way the installed Debian appears in the Grub list, but > it still won't boot. I'd rather have it on the new 2TB drive rather > than the three-year-old 1TB drive, but that probably also doesn't > matter. > > > I bet if you removed t

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread John Jason Jordan
I'm back in Ubuntu, following my ninth failed attempt to install Debian 12. But I should say at the beginning that, like Rich, I've used ext4 for many years and have never had a problem. My issues with installing Debian 12 is that it won't boot because of a failure in setting up Grub. And the root

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread Rich Shepard
On Tue, 19 Sep 2023, Ben Koenig wrote: Back to Rich's original question though you don't configure your filesystem with fdisk. If you already have drives that are actively in use then you can leave the partitions alone, and just reformat with mkfs. Slackware also includes several /sbin/mkfs.

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread Ben Koenig
I can't find a link to share at the moment, but I remember reading some comments from an interview with one of the EXT4 developers where he said that while there are some issues, EXT4 is extremely robust when it comes to recovering from data corruption. Basically he was saying that it tends to

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread Michael Ewan
I am glad you have not had any problems. I have had the opposite experience with ext4 but never a problem with xfs, hence my suggestion. On Tue, Sep 19, 2023 at 1:25 PM Rich Shepard wrote: > On Tue, 19 Sep 2023, Michael Ewan wrote: > > > You will ultimately have problems with a corrupted file s

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread Rich Shepard
On Tue, 19 Sep 2023, Michael Ewan wrote: You will ultimately have problems with a corrupted file system with ext4, almost guaranteed. Xfs is a much more robust file system but if you do not trust it, then try zfs or btrfs. Michael, I've used ext2, ext3, and ext4 with no issues on any of them

Re: [PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-19 Thread Michael Ewan
You will ultimately have problems with a corrupted file system with ext4, almost guaranteed. Xfs is a much more robust file system but if you do not trust it, then try zfs or btrfs. On Sun, Sep 17, 2023 at 6:26 AM Rich Shepard wrote: > A while ago, when I had backup issues with the logical volu

[PLUG] Change hard drive FS

2023-09-17 Thread Rich Shepard
A while ago, when I had backup issues with the logical volume on the external MediaSonic Pro enclosure, I removed the LV and formatted the two drives to xfs upon advice here. My dirvish backup is on /dev/sde1 and when that's done rsync copies daily changes to /dev/sdf1. I've since learned that xf