Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-05 Thread Lisa Kachold
Can anyone chime in on using enterprise mass systems configuration and management tools? What are you using? Chef, Puppet or CFEngine and why? I have configured Chef, and setup and demonstrated puppet for specific unique tasks (hackfest configuration and password files), both ruby based. I see t

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-05 Thread James Mcphee
I am also looking at implementing one of these at some point in the near future. The standard scripts over ssh is simple and relatively well controlled, but teaching new people how to use them and maintaining them in a sane fashion is troublesome. I've used a few HP, Dell, Sun, and IBM config pro

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-06 Thread Ed
On Sat, Nov 5, 2011 at 4:59 PM, James Mcphee wrote: > I am also looking at implementing one of these at some point in the near > future.  The standard scripts over ssh is simple and relatively well > controlled, but teaching new people how to use them and maintaining them in > a sane fashion is tr

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-08 Thread Bryan O'Neal
Personal opinion - for large scale use with many people maintaining different sections puppet is one of the best - however it is really only good for file management. Since nearly everything on a linux system is a file, this should not be a problem. As for user management - I am still under the opi

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-08 Thread Lisa Kachold
Thanks to all who responded. I believe this is an excellent subject for a blog after about 10,000 lab testing package comparison hours! Laugh! On Tue, Nov 8, 2011 at 9:34 AM, Bryan O'Neal < bryan.on...@theonealandassociates.com> wrote: > Personal opinion - for large scale use with many people mai

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-09 Thread Dan Dubovik
We currently use puppet. We have used it for quite some time, and just revisited our configuration management system, to see if it was still the right way to go. In looking at Chef, CFEngine and Puppet, we decided to stick with Puppet. The cost of changing over a number of extremely complex syst

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-09 Thread Kevin Fries
At my work, we use AD for access across all our Windows and Linux servers. Then we use puppet to manage consistent permissions on the /etc/sudoers file, auto_home, and ssh access. This combination works great!!! On Nov 9, 2011 4:24 PM, "Dan Dubovik" wrote: > We currently use puppet. We have use

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-10 Thread Brandon
I'm glad to see this discussion because I was just starting to research using Puppet or Chef to help manage a new web server environment I helped to build. I've not used either before. We have a small number of servers so far and scripts are fine for now but using one of these tools would make my l

Re: Puppet, Chef or CFEngine?

2011-11-10 Thread Scott
Has anyone had any experience using Puppet to manage read-only root / diskless clients? RedHat / CentOS used to have a utility to do this (system-config-notboot), but it has been deprecated as of 6.0. Reading through 5.7's rc.sysinit, it makes references to moving towards using Puppet to manage t