Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-17 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
I will be dedicating one page on this discussion on my website. http://desaiyn.tripod.com After joining this group i found that there are 233 hits already there seems good group out there in Pune. -- __ Pune GNU/Linux Users

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-17 Thread Varun Mehta
Guys one Point I liked mentioned above was 1. Demands decides what is avaialbe. - Truly speaking Pirated Windows is what is in Demand Well with Windoz Vista "security" for pirated softwares getting tougher by the day gives us an opportunity, to spread Linux awareness as FREE and EASY to use wit

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
LPG/Diesel came in discussion as govt defying Free market as a "policy". While for creating demand was at the back of the mind when I made the first post. . I think best way to creat demand for Linux Desktop is enforce law and eleminate pirated windows. Yagnesh >>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 14/11/

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
Cool I like it, so many point of views. I might compile them with my Point of view: 1. Demands decides what is avaialbe. - Truly speaking Pirated Windows is what is in Demand 2. Company sells hardware while drivers are "courtesy" - I cannot cope with it I buy a car while stearing comes as a "

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Desi Penguin
policy to promote something which is better for country. Subsidy on LPG, Urea & Diesel are just few to mention is this free country. Same also I'm no lawayer and don't claim to understand what is PIL, but how can we compare LPG/Diesel etc with Linux support ? I can understand PIL in terms of p

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Manas Alekar
The company sells you the hardware. The drivers come as a courtesy or a service as Aditya has been saying. So, what do we petition against ? Manas -- __ Pune GNU/Linux Users Group Mailing List: (plug-mail@plug.org.in) List

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Aditya Godbole
On 11/14/06, YAGNESH N DESAI <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: My dear friend you are taking the argument too far in tangent. Please note that I am telling that my right to choose is hampered 'cos "Windows only" CD is supplied with the hardware. Your right to choose is limited by whats available in t

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Manas Alekar
Yes, a manufacturer can sell a car without a steering. If most people start buying them, will you file a PIL ? If the manufacturer prints in bold on the handouts with fancy logos a big banner saying "STEERING" not included, and people still buy it, will the court let you file a PIL ? Manas -- ___

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
My dear friend you are taking the argument too far in tangent. >The government should not have any such policy. Every individual has a >right to choose for himself and the market moves according to what >majority of the individuals choose. Please note that I am telling that my right to choose i

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Aditya Godbole
On 11/14/06, YAGNESH N DESAI <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: First thing is that it is known that one can go to any shop and check 99% of the IT hardwares and services are only provided with "Windows only" support. The idea here is why should a country like India (which has to import these hardwares)

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
First thing is that it is known that one can go to any shop and check 99% of the IT hardwares and services are only provided with "Windows only" support. The idea here is why should a country like India (which has to import these hardwares) have a policy to import and sell a hardware which a

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-14 Thread Aditya Godbole
On 11/11/06, YAGNESH N DESAI <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Friends; PIL came to my mind 'cos of provided limited choice by Indian Service providers and manufacturers. Hi, The way I see it, the company is providing a service. You cannot file a PIL against the company because it refuses to provide

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-13 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
Thanks Sridhar; Your point well taken. On point no 1 I will be surly looking for a verdict. Also my broad vision is that Govt. should have policy where it discourages new enterant with single O/S or software support. I can ask for the specifications to the vendors. But being a novice on h

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-13 Thread श्रीधर नारायण दैठणकर
On Saturday 11 November 2006 12:18, Aditya Laghate wrote: > On 11/11/06, YAGNESH N DESAI <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Friends; > > > > PIL came to my mind 'cos of provided limited choice by > > Indian Service providers and manufacturers. > > > > Can one file PIL saying all the Generic Hardware ve

Re: [PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-10 Thread Aditya Laghate
On 11/11/06, YAGNESH N DESAI <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Friends; PIL came to my mind 'cos of provided limited choice by Indian Service providers and manufacturers. Can one file PIL saying all the Generic Hardware vendors & generic IT service providers need to ship drivers for at least one othe

[PLUG] Can we file PIL (Public Interest Litigation)

2006-11-10 Thread YAGNESH N DESAI
Friends; PIL came to my mind 'cos of provided limited choice by Indian Service providers and manufacturers. I have seen that all the cams/Printers/Scanners/Internet wireless Modems (Reliance, Indicom even BSNL) and many hardware come with only windows support. ie the manufacturer/service prov