Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-25 Thread Alexander Gataric
What parameter file settings are you using? I got low CPU utilization on 11.6 with postgis 2.4. ⁣Get BlueMail for Android ​ On Feb 25, 2020, 3:31 AM, at 3:31 AM, Stefan Duling wrote: >Sorry there is a major typor in my previous mail with the postgres >version. Each time i wrote 10.4 it has to

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-25 Thread Paul Ramsey
Yes, please, if you draw a sample of your tables can you still see the big time difference in your queries? We cannot easily test against your production data because (a) we don't have it and (b) it would take us a long time to just prepare it. I would love to fix this because you seem to have nail

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-25 Thread Imre Samu
Hi Stefan, > I haven’t tested the newly released postgis 3.0.1 since there is no easy installation so far (as long as I see). If you can create a minimal reproducible example [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimal_working_example ] then the core developers can easily replicate, debug and fix thi

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-25 Thread Stefan Duling
Sorry there is a major typor in my previous mail with the postgres version. Each time i wrote 10.4 it has to be 10.12. Corrected version: Hello everyone, I just want to report the outcomes of my latest performance research. Postgres 12.1 and Postgres 12.2 are both restrictively slow in perfor

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-25 Thread Stefan Duling
Hello everyone, I just want to report the outcomes of my latest performance research. Postgres 12.1 and Postgres 12.2 are both restrictively slow in performing our geometry processing queries - no matter what postgis version (3.0.0, 2.5) I use and how the raw data came into the db. Setting jit

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-20 Thread Stefan Duling
Hi Imre, thanks for showing the other discussions. It really seems like it’s a very similar problem. I tried: - jit = off - max_parallel_workers_per_gather = 0 - jit = off with max_parallel_workers_per_gather = 0 - ANALYZE osm_admin_areas; before the query Sadly those options have not the effe

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-20 Thread Imre Samu
Hi Stefan, > I tried Postgis 2.5 on the new setup with Postgres 12.1. I can’t see any significant differences. Please re-test with: - "ANALYZE osm_admin_areas; " AND " jit=off max_parallel_workers_per_gather=0" parameters based on similar problem: https://github.com/openstreetmap/osm2pgsq

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-20 Thread Stefan Duling
Hi Paul, thanks for your response! I tried Postgis 2.5 on the new setup with Postgres 12.1. I can’t see any significant differences. I also tried to use only one worker per gatherer. Although there is a little improvement, the query time still is doubled compared to the old setup with Postgres

Re: [postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-19 Thread Paul Ramsey
If you can cut this down to a smaller, shorter query that shows the same characteristics, I would like to see it in a profiler to determine if the hot spots have moved. The explain seems more or less structurally the same, which leaves a couple possibilities: - the st_collect running in parallel

[postgis-users] Performance Postgres12/Postgis3 vs Postgres10/Postgis2.4

2020-02-19 Thread Stefan Duling
Hi everyone, at the moment I am trying out a new setup for our geo database server. Primarily I upgraded from Postgres and Postgis to newer versions. Beside of the memory both databases run on the same machine setups and contain identical data. Differences are: OLD SETUP 16GB RAM Postgres 10.