RE: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-03 Thread Stasha Lauria
G Listserve; Stefano Federici Subject: Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming Stasha, your paper is unclear (at least to me) what assessment you were using. You describe the rubric: The use of loops, conditional, etc. to achieve the given task was part of the marking crit

Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-02 Thread Guzdial, Mark
/download.php?file=italics/vol10iss1/pdfs/paper10.pdf I hope this helps. Regards, Stasha From: Stefano Federici [sfeder...@unica.it] Sent: 01 March 2011 14:29 To: PPIG Listserve Cc: Stefano Federici Subject: Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer

RE: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-02 Thread Stasha Lauria
/download.php?file=italics/vol10iss1/pdfs/paper10.pdf I hope this helps. Regards, Stasha From: Stefano Federici [sfeder...@unica.it] Sent: 01 March 2011 14:29 To: PPIG Listserve Cc: Stefano Federici Subject: Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-01 Thread Thomas Green
On 1 Mar 2011, at 14:29, Stefano Federici wrote: Do you have any references to similar evalutations? Now that Alan and Chuck have made the text of 'Psychology if Programming' available again, you might start there. Also look for work by Jorma Sajaniemi in Finland, and for lots of work by

Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-01 Thread Stefano Federici
Thanks a lot Thomas and John for your suggestions. To better clarify my settings, I have two new tools (aiming at teaching two different topics: general programming the first, sorting algorithms the second) that I want to compare against NOT using the tools. Do you have any references to

Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-01 Thread John Daughtry
I would suggest taking a more holistic view of the design space. Rather than asking which tool is best, you may be better served by seeking to empirically describe and explain the underlying trade-offs. In what ways do option1 help, hinder, and undermine learning? In what ways do option2 help, hind

Re: evalutation of new tools to teach computer programming

2011-03-01 Thread Thomas Green
Depending on your aims, you might want to measure transfer to other problems: that is, do participants who used tool A for the sorting task, then do better when tackling a new problem, possibly with a different tool, than participants who used tool B? You might also want to look at memory