Re: [PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread Simon Peacock
I would agree with his statements.. but there is other equally important considerations. First thing is use the component centre as the component origin. It will save you headacks later, Place it on a metric (1mm) grid even if the rest of the board is placed on an imperial grid. (But move your

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Bevan Weiss
I've only got one 300MHz line, and one 200MHz line, the 300MHz is a Thevenin termination, and the 200MHz is a series termination. Thanks for the advice. - Original Message - From: "Richard Sumner" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Protel EDA Forum" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Saturday, September 28

Re: [PEDA] Guard Traces

2002-09-27 Thread Jon Elson
Robison Michael R CNIN wrote: > Hello, > > I've drawn a schematic and now I'm attempting to interactively > route the traces to match some old artwork, but I've run into > some guard traces that I haven't got in the schematic. At > least I think they are guard traces. They have a via to GND > a

Re: [PEDA] Guard Traces

2002-09-27 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 09:01 AM 9/27/2002 -0500, Robison Michael R CNIN wrote: >I've drawn a schematic and now I'm attempting to interactively >route the traces to match some old artwork, but I've run into >some guard traces that I haven't got in the schematic. At >least I think they are guard traces. They have a v

Re: [PEDA] OT - Complex boards and time to Layout? - Shorted Planes

2002-09-27 Thread Jon Elson
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Run a couple of amps (from a current limited power supply) through the short and > use a 5 1/2 digit voltmeter on the millivolt range and you can get the short > circuit location fairly easily. Yes, that's the procedure. But, with perhaps 500 holes tied to the ground

Re: [PEDA] Bug / Buglet

2002-09-27 Thread Dwight
I recall some option that can be set to "include single-pin nets" -- this might give you net-names for all those unconnected pins, then the usual 'update primitives from connected copper' (or whatever) would take care of this. I can't readily test this right now, but maybe it's enough to help...

Re: [PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread JaMi Smith
Juha, Just looked at your database. First, your vias are misplaced, and need to be exactly in the center of the opening between the pads, which appear to be on a 1mm grid, which means that you vias should be on a .5mm grid. This will keep your vias as far as possible from the actual BGA pad, and

Re: [PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread JaMi Smith
Juha, It seems that everyone is missing the primary questions. What is the speed of the device? What type of routing are you doing, TTL / CMOS, ECL, LVDS, etc., etc., etc.? How many of the actual I/O's are you actually using? Where are all of your I?O's going to or comming from (do most of th

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Bagotronix Tech Support
Richard: Sorry, I guess I didn't read your posting well enough (once is not always enough!). We didn't need to worry about this stuff back in the days of TTL and metal-gate CMOS. I used to see big, long backplanes with big, bold tracks on 2-sided PCBs, and big, long stubs (plug-in cards), and i

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Richard Sumner
Ivan, I agree completely. However I did note that clocks and strobes should be clean, perhaps not emphatically enough though! One way to reduce the overshoot on an unterminated trace is to really load the drivers. For example, by making the trace Z as low as you can (a wide trace and a small

Re: [PEDA] Guard Traces

2002-09-27 Thread dave . e . lewis
Miker, I belive if you were to _first_ place your via such that it only cuts through the ground plane and not any other copper, then the via will automatically picks up GND as its net assignment. Now, if you start placing your guard traces _starting from the via_ then those too would automati

Re: [PEDA] OT - bd testing

2002-09-27 Thread Bagotronix Tech Support
We need to come up with some kind of online blacklist (or whitelist) of PCB fabs. I certainly would not want to be a victim of inadequate (or fraudulent) board testing. How could we do this? Some sort of blog with anecdotal entries? Best regards, Ivan Baggett Bagotronix Inc. website: www.bago

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Bagotronix Tech Support
> The rise time is not as important as you might think. You said 30 MHz is I disagree. The problem is when you have devices that are clocked by strobes. Enough ringing on that strobe can cause metastability and/or multiple clocking. If the ringing is bad enough to cause a non-monotonic transit

Re: [PEDA] Guard Traces

2002-09-27 Thread John Branthoover
Hello, I just created a one pin schematic part. Called a guard and connected the pin to ground in the schematic. The footprint for this part is just a through hole pad. I hope the this helps. -Original Message- From: Robison Michael R CNIN [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: F

[PEDA] Guard Traces

2002-09-27 Thread Robison Michael R CNIN
Hello, I've drawn a schematic and now I'm attempting to interactively route the traces to match some old artwork, but I've run into some guard traces that I haven't got in the schematic. At least I think they are guard traces. They have a via to GND at one end and follow beside another trace fo

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Richard Sumner
Brian, The rise time is not as important as you might think. You said 30 MHz is the frequency. If that means that there is 30 nanoseconds between edges, you can probably ignore terminations on the data lines. There will be some ringing for a few reflection times (perhaps 5-10 ns) but then the

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Jason Morgan
Try doing a model in Protel using the signal integrity function. Don't try the whole bus, just one circuit, get the IO technology, lengths, widths, shape and board layup and material correct and you'll get a reasonably close simulation - or at least I did. Assuming you're not going to let more t

Re: [PEDA] OT: termination for a multidrop bidirectional bus

2002-09-27 Thread Bevan Weiss
Unfortuneately not. I've got the trial version of HyperLynx here, but it doesn't allow the simulation of custom made setups. I've had a couple of setups simulated by a contact in the industry that has access to the full version, this is what put me onto needing the termination. However, it isn'

Re: [PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread Bevan Weiss
How would you even solder a 1020pin BGA (I assume that's 32x32 with the four central balls missing?) I say that you'd need to use blind vias, with a lot of layers (I've never worked on BGA's but would imagine that you might get 4rows/columns per layer). My estimate would require around 8layers.

Re: [PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread Emanuel Zimmermann
Hei Juha, I currently don't have the time to work out a detailed routing strategy, but if I hear of such a biest I would consider blind/buried vias. If you choose to go to microvias you even can place them within the BGA pads! Depending the overall complexity I would recommend a 2+N+2 stack in

Re: [PEDA] Simulation Function Block, PWLR

2002-09-27 Thread Rolf Molitor
Thomas, but what kind of signal do you want to model with the 'PWLR' ? Is it a voltage like with VPWL or a current as with IPWL (with time/value pairs as parameters) ? Where can i find this part 'PWLR', where can i find the library you got it from (what .ddb is it in) ? Maybe the 'PWLR' does take

[PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question (some add)

2002-09-27 Thread Juha Pajunen
Hi again, <> What is the best PCB layer stack for this type of BGA? <> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/protel-users/files/junk/ There is 1020-pin 1mm pitch BGA. It would be very pleasing to have some information and help how to route that huge BGA. What are trace width and cap between different t

[PEDA] 1020-pin BGA out-routing question

2002-09-27 Thread Juha Pajunen
Hi, I just uploaded 1020-BGA_ROUTING_TEST.ddb here http://groups.yahoo.com/group/protel-users/files/junk/ There is 1020-pin 1mm pitch BGA. It would be very pleasing to have some information and help how to route that huge BGA. What are trace width and cap between different tracks and so... It w