Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-29 Thread Antoine Isaac
You're right, Dave--thanks for the correction! And thanks to Bernard for the additional case. Though there might be a problem with owl:hasValue and "it does not prevent an instance of such a class to belong to another skos:ConceptScheme". My previous owl:someValuesFrom was perhaps a bit more fi

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-29 Thread Bernard Vatant
Hi all I'm with Antoine and Dave on this - as previously written (I think). owl:hasValue is indeed a nice and too much overlooked OWL construct allowing to define a class based on any property-value pair, e.g., "A "Blue Thing" is a Thing of which property "color" has value "Blue" ex:BlueThing a

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-29 Thread Dave Reynolds
On 28/08/12 20:39, Antoine Isaac wrote: Sorry, my owl:someValuesFrom should have been owl:allValuesFrom, I guess. Actually I think owl:someValuesFrom is right though the easiest construct is owl:hasValue : some:codeAConcept owl:equivalentClass [ owl:intersectionOf ( skos:Concept

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-28 Thread Antoine Isaac
Sorry, my owl:someValuesFrom should have been owl:allValuesFrom, I guess. Antoine Hi Thomas, all, I disagree with you on the fact that sub-classing skos:Concept would solve all representation needs. There is data to be asserted at the concept scheme-level, which would be inappropriately cap

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-28 Thread Antoine Isaac
Hi Thomas, all, I disagree with you on the fact that sub-classing skos:Concept would solve all representation needs. There is data to be asserted at the concept scheme-level, which would be inappropriately captured when being directly attached to a class of concepts. E.g., the creator of a con

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-24 Thread Hans Cools
> Simon Cox > > -----Original Message----- > From: Thomas Bandholtz [mailto:thomas.bandho...@innoq.com] > Sent: Thursday, 23 August 2012 8:07 AM > To: public-esw-t...@w3.org; > Cc: dave.e.reyno...@gmail.com; san...@w3.org; Till Schulte-Coerne > Subject: Re: referencing a concep

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-23 Thread Dave Reynolds
On 23/08/12 10:22, Thomas Bandholtz wrote: Am 23.08.2012 10:40, schrieb Dave Reynolds: [Apologies for continuing the cross-posting] A pattern of using sub-classes of skos:Concept to denote a group of concepts (and thus be able to use rdfs:range in associated ontologies) is a good one. It is rec

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-23 Thread Bernard Vatant
er one? > > Rather, I'd say that the property you're after indicates that some > > concepts from these two concept schemes are connected. For this I > > think one could use general linkage properties between datasets, such > > as voiD's linksets [2]. >

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-23 Thread Thomas Bandholtz
Am 23.08.2012 10:40, schrieb Dave Reynolds: > [Apologies for continuing the cross-posting] > > A pattern of using sub-classes of skos:Concept to denote a group of > concepts (and thus be able to use rdfs:range in associated ontologies) > is a good one. It is recommended best practice in data.gov.uk

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-23 Thread Dave Reynolds
[Apologies for continuing the cross-posting] A pattern of using sub-classes of skos:Concept to denote a group of concepts (and thus be able to use rdfs:range in associated ontologies) is a good one. It is recommended best practice in data.gov.uk linked data work, for example. This does not r

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-23 Thread Thomas Bandholtz
> -Original Message- > From: Thomas Bandholtz [mailto:thomas.bandho...@innoq.com] > Sent: Thursday, 23 August 2012 8:07 AM > To: public-esw-t...@w3.org; > Cc: dave.e.reyno...@gmail.com; san...@w3.org; Till Schulte-Coerne > Subject: Re: referencing a concept scheme as the c

RE: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-22 Thread Simon.Cox
ssage- From: Thomas Bandholtz [mailto:thomas.bandho...@innoq.com] Sent: Thursday, 23 August 2012 8:07 AM To: public-esw-t...@w3.org; Cc: dave.e.reyno...@gmail.com; san...@w3.org; Till Schulte-Coerne Subject: Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-22 Thread Thomas Bandholtz
ibuted, although it can be found in the archive. > http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-swd-wg/2012Aug/.html > public-swd...@w3.org isn't very active any more, so public-lod@w3.org > might be a better place. > > Best regards, > Thomas > > > Original-Nachr

Re: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-22 Thread Antoine Isaac
lic/public-swd-wg/2012Aug/.html public-swd...@w3.org isn't very active any more, so public-lod@w3.org might be a better place. Best regards, Thomas -------- Original-Nachricht ---- Betreff: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property Datum:

referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property

2012-08-19 Thread Thomas Bandholtz
c-lod@w3.org might be a better place. Best regards, Thomas Original-Nachricht Betreff: referencing a concept scheme as the code list of some referrer's property Datum: Sun, 19 Aug 2012 10:50:05 +0200 Von:Thomas Bandholtz An: public-swd...@w3.org Hi SKO