Re: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread William Bug
Very sensible question, Nigam. Unfortunately, the nature of this data - both the atlas and each of these 20,000 GenePainted brains is 2D. The GenePainted brains - despite having been There are statistical techniques used to make assertions about 3D anatomical objects from 2D-based data (

Re: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread kc28
Hi Bill, Maryann, Thanks for your great response to the GIS queries of the brain. I absolutely agree it's not a trivial issue to create canonical coordinates that will work for different types/instances of brains, while there is only one earth! Bill, you're also right on the target for my qu

Fwd: [Psidev-announce] In Public Comment: Guidelines for the development of Controlled Vocabularies

2007-03-04 Thread frank gibson
Hello The Proteomics Standards Initiative have developed a Community Practice document on "Guidelines for the development of Controlled Vocabularies. This document was designed initially to guide the development of the PSI and MSI Controlled vocabularies. However it may be suitable across domains

Re: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread Maryann Martone
This is exactly what BIRN has been working on through the Smart Atlas project and now MBAT. The inverse query is also true: What genes are expressed here? As Bill indicated, there are several spatially normalized atlas projects (ABA, GEnepaint) that can do that. We've been working on spat

Re: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread Alan Ruttenberg
Because it was easy to do a proof of concept with it, and because there are lots of freely available code snippets[1] to add functionality to it should we want to go in that direction. If you had a look you can see that I didn't have to write much code, which is the way I like it :) Not

RE: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread Nigam Shah
I did pass some emails around to the SMART Atlas folks early last week in order to get their feedback on Alan's work on the Google Maps Javascript API and backend PERL code to support caching images. The Google Maps API is one that has come up endless in these atlasing discussions, and it's nice to

Re: Spatial queries against GENSAT or ABA

2007-03-04 Thread William Bug
Given the UNIQUE work BIRN, your lab, and Ilya have done in applying GIS techniques to this problem of creating a SPATIAL-QUERY capable brain atlasing system (the SMART Atlas), it would be wonderful if Ilya could vet the scenarios as I outline them below. This is my best understanding of w