Re: relationships between parts, molecules, and cells in BAMS

2007-03-22 Thread John Rumble
There was some pretty powerful thinking that went into this, so it might be worth looking at. ISO 10303 is a pretty expensive standard, but a copy of the relevant sections probably can be obtained from someone still at NIST, which I left about 3 years ago. John Rumble Vice President Information Inte

Re: how to deal with different requirements for experiment self-publishing

2006-07-07 Thread John Rumble
ulti-tasking of a prototype ontology that can be exercised and learned from. The diversity of approaches across science is just too large to get it right the first time.   John Rumble   p.s. Several weeks ago I mentioned some work on nomenclature and linguistic barriers to scientific data standar

Re: scientific publishing task force update

2006-06-13 Thread John Rumble
An unwritten rule about higher level ontologies is that they reflect our knowledge today, not tomorrow. As knowledge evolves, the upper level ontologies, especially, must also evolve. The example of the concept "protein" is very apropos here. We can view it from  functional, structural, inte

Re: scientific publishing task force update

2006-06-09 Thread John Rumble
There has been some important work done on this subject over the last 20 years. A. Shoshoni, F. Olken and others wrote some very insightful papers about differentiating between different types of independent variables in an experiment. I have given several talks in recent years about the pro