Re: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-27 Thread Jeremy J Carroll
Hi Bob I am a message behind in my thinking, thanks for all your input. My use case is a lot less clear than it could be … in that the contribution I am seeking to make lies somewhere in the tool-chain, not at the very bottom, but also not right next to the scientists or clinicians working wit

RE: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-26 Thread Freimuth, Robert R., Ph.D.
Jeremy J Carroll [mailto:j...@syapse.com] Sent: Tuesday, March 26, 2013 3:30 PM To: Freimuth, Robert R., Ph.D. Cc: w3c semweb HCLS Subject: Re: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling Hi Bob In this message I reply to It will certainly be important to track metadata about the sequ

Re: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-26 Thread Jeremy J Carroll
Hi Bob In this message I reply to > It will certainly be important to track metadata about the sequence analysis > method, etc. but not to > In my opinion, the real potential of using semweb technologies with genetic > data is in the layers of interpretation that are built from the genetic

RE: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-26 Thread Freimuth, Robert R., Ph.D.
> H, there are a lot of modeling questions in there. The adage "all models are wrong, but some are useful" comes to mind. To answer these questions, you need to define your use cases. What are you trying to model? Why? How is the data going to be used? Are you trying to model the sequen

Re: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-21 Thread Michel Dumontier
On Thu, Mar 21, 2013 at 6:00 PM, Jeremy J Carroll wrote: > > Jerven suggests: > > "instead of saying chrM it would have been solved by > using > http://my.lab.org/confidential/patientXXYYZZ/genome/sampleXX/ChrM/assemblyTTv43/VariantCalls5 > " > > rather than continuing the philosophical/theologic

Re: 'Variants' and Chromosome Modelling

2013-03-21 Thread Joachim Baran
On 2013-03-21, at 6:00 PM, Jeremy J Carroll wrote: > "instead of saying chrM it would have been solved by > using > http://my.lab.org/confidential/patientXXYYZZ/genome/sampleXX/ChrM/assemblyTTv43/VariantCalls5"; > In this way of thinking, I am not really interested in an assembly of ChrM > for