Re: Editorial Control

2007-01-25 Thread Doug Schepers
Hi, Ian- Ian Hickson wrote: As you say, the WG here just moved from one minority opinion to another minority opinion. So this isn't a case where Anne's decision was not representative of the wider community. You're implying with the term "minority opinion" that there was a "majority opini

Re: Editorial Control (was: Selectors API naming)

2007-01-25 Thread Ian Hickson
On Thu, 25 Jan 2007, Doug Schepers wrote: > > [...] I made exactly the point that you did -- you should have an editor who makes decisions, but can be overriden by a working group when the decisions are not representative of the community. As you say, the WG here just moved from one minority o

Editorial Control (was: Selectors API naming)

2007-01-25 Thread Doug Schepers
Ian Hickson wrote: On Thu, 25 Jan 2007, João Eiras wrote: So, it's a matter of personal opinion that "names suck". My argument is not that the names suck. My argument is that there is not concensus, that the decision process was opaque and behind-closed-doors, The discussion was not done