Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread Trevor Vaughan
Honestly, it seems like the majority is to not have this, so I'm happy to drop it if that's the consensus. I just keep running into the usual situation where I don't want dangling links. For the other items: if the catalog *does* fail on account of the link's target not being > managed soon enoug

Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread John Bollinger
On Monday, March 2, 2015 at 1:50:08 PM UTC-6, Trevor Vaughan wrote: > > Well, there's my concrete example of where dangling symlinks are used in > the wild > > Ok, back to autorequires. I'm still not convinced that it's beneficial to > not have it in place. > I am unlikely to persuade you

Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread Trevor Vaughan
Well, there's my concrete example of where dangling symlinks are used in the wild Ok, back to autorequires. I'm still not convinced that it's beneficial to not have it in place. I suppose that I could do some hack-fu like I did with 'group' so that people that want it could patch it into plac

Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread Reid Vandewiele
On Monday, March 2, 2015 at 7:21:55 AM UTC-8, Trevor Vaughan wrote: > > HmmOk, how about this: > > 1) Dangling symlinks are allowed > 2) Warnings on dangling symlinks are the default (because you *probably* > don't want them) > 3) Setting :force => true, disables the warning message (in theory

Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread Trevor Vaughan
HmmOk, how about this: 1) Dangling symlinks are allowed 2) Warnings on dangling symlinks are the default (because you *probably* don't want them) 3) Setting :force => true, disables the warning message (in theory, you would only do this after seeing the message) 3a) For a less destructive meth

Re: [Puppet-dev] Autorequiring parent directories to the home directory in user resources

2015-03-02 Thread John Bollinger
On Friday, February 27, 2015 at 2:51:03 PM UTC-6, Trevor Vaughan wrote: > > Ok, you certainly have a working counter example, but I feel that it > *should* actually fail and that this is a bug. > > [...] > I would like to propose that symlinks should naturally (i.e. autorequire*) > come *a