Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-21 Thread Peter Nijssen
Thanks for your answer. I've only been a week now in the world of puppet. I started to use it, because I am charmed with the puppet + vagrant combination as a developer. Also, we currently are managing a growing number of servers by hand and I believe puppet can be a nice answer to keep

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-21 Thread Jason Antman
Nijssen peternijs...@gmail.com Date: 2013/12/21 08:00 (GMT-05:00) To: puppet-users@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest? Thanks for your answer. I've only been a week now in the world of puppet. I started to use it, because I am charmed with the puppet + vagrant

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-21 Thread Chad Huneycutt
Hi Peter, Your instinct is correct. Just like many programming languages that allow you to keep all of your code in one file (or one function, even), it's not a good idea. As you mentioned, you can use import to pull in other files, but the better solution is to use puppet's autoloading

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-21 Thread Peter Nijssen
) To: puppet...@googlegroups.com javascript: Subject: Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest? Thanks for your answer. I've only been a week now in the world of puppet. I started to use it, because I am charmed with the puppet + vagrant combination as a developer. Also, we currently are managing

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-21 Thread Peter Nijssen
Hi Chad, Greet to hear that my instinct was correct. As noted in the docs of puppet, using import is not recommended. So that's why I didn't want to use that either. So basically my configuration should be in modules. That was basically my biggest problem. Let's say I use a apache module from

[Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-20 Thread Peter Nijssen
Hi, I started to use vagrant with puphpet https://puphpet.com/. Very nice. However, the gui of puphpet gives me too few options, so I want to configure everything myself. So, I decided to write everything from scratch, using modules. Modules like apache, mysql, php, phpmyadmin which are in the

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-20 Thread Christopher Wood
Looks like you might want to start here: http://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/modules_fundamentals.html Also check up on how to do hiera lookups from within puppet3. Other than that, structuring your modules tends to be a bit site-dependent. On Fri, Dec 20, 2013 at 08:38:03AM

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-20 Thread Peter Nijssen
I read that document, however, it doesn't provide me the answer. Should I write, in general, my own modules? Or should I use predefined modules? And I if use predefined modules, should the configuration of those modules happen all in site.pp? (Which sounds me like a big file which is getting

Re: [Puppet Users] One big manifest?

2013-12-20 Thread Johan De Wit
This is just a question with so many answers. have you tried the puppet enterprise quick start guide ? It is a good way to learn the concepts and get you started quickly. Get in touch with local puppet users. Looks to me you are dutch speaking, so get in touch with the dutch or belgian