[python-committers] Re: PEP 581/588 RFC: Collecting feedback about GitHub Issues

2019-10-13 Thread Senthil Kumaran
Hi Guido, > But I do want to emphasize that not everyone experiences the same dread when requested to use a GitHub issue that you and Raymond seem to feel. If I understand this correctly, it was not about the dread, but the overall context already preserved in this discussion. The feedback

[python-committers] Re: PEP 581/588 RFC: Collecting feedback about GitHub Issues

2019-10-13 Thread Guido van Rossum
TBH, for me it's quite the opposite. There are too many mailing list threads and it's often hard to catch up on them because there's a lot of pointless back and forth and quite frequently the discussion diverges to topics that are not of interest. I am used to having many important design

[python-committers] Re: PEP 581/588 RFC: Collecting feedback about GitHub Issues

2019-10-13 Thread Paul Moore
I have to say that I agree with Raymond here. I don't think that an issue tracker is a good way to collect this sort of feedback. To be honest, I don't feel that there's going to be much scope to address the sorts of concerns being raised here, so I'm not clear how much value there will be in the