Re: [Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-05 Thread Andreas Neumann
Hi, Well, if someone works on improving the intersection functions it would make sense to introduce a threshold value to allow to ignore area/area intersections with very small overlaps (e.g. very small sliver polygons overlapping). But I doubt that all of this would happen by itself without

Re: [Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-05 Thread Andreas Neumann
Am 05.06.2014 06:46, schrieb G. Allegri: Hi Andreas, I'm doing it :) ah good! As you can see I've added the checkox options to have fine control on spatial relations. I could add the threashold value as well. I know we are in feature freeze, I'm doing it for the next 2.5/2.6. Should I wait

[Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-04 Thread G. Allegri
I've done some testing with fTools' spatial join and select by location tools. Whatever the geometry type it uses the intersects operator, which is true even if geometries only touch. I've patched my own version to distinguish the case the input layer (to be selected) is a linear or polygonal

Re: [Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-04 Thread Alex Mandel
On 06/04/2014 09:42 AM, G. Allegri wrote: I've done some testing with fTools' spatial join and select by location tools. Whatever the geometry type it uses the intersects operator, which is true even if geometries only touch. I've patched my own version to distinguish the case the input

Re: [Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-04 Thread G. Allegri
Both options should exist. Perhaps a checkbox to exclude those that only touch? Admittedly, in my own version I have three checkboxes: - include layers that only touch - include layers that only overlaps - include layers the are completely contained and they are all checked by default

Re: [Qgis-developer] spatial joins and select by location should not consider polygons than only touch

2014-06-04 Thread G. Allegri
Here it is my proposal: http://cdn.img42.com/5bbc189562f621af883671ee59e60ff7.png giovanni 2014-06-04 18:58 GMT+02:00 G. Allegri gioha...@gmail.com: Both options should exist. Perhaps a checkbox to exclude those that only touch? Admittedly, in my own version I have three checkboxes: -