Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-09-07 Thread Peng, C
In addition to Cedric's comments, these are large sample procedures. Your sample sizes are two small. I don't think any procedures using normal approximations are inappropriate for your case. I would suggest making a reasonable distribution on the populations to avoid asymptotic results. -- View

Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-09-07 Thread Chloe
Sorry that I did not answer you earlier, I would like to thank you again for your advice and the time you dedicated to my problem. In my case it was not possible to increase the sample size but I would take your advice into account for the next sampling and also for presenting these results! Th

Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-08-21 Thread Cedric Laczny
Glad that I could help :) Another thing that came to my mind ist that when you simply look at the values of the different groups, they differ quite strongly in my opinion. They are between two and three times higher in the second group than the ones from the first group. Therefore it would be a

Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-08-21 Thread Chloe
Hi Cedric, Thanks a lot for your help, after calculating U value using the formula from wikipedia I also found that the W given by R was in fact the U value that I could directly compared to table of critical value. Your advice were really good and useful. I would also be careful with the conclusi

Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-08-20 Thread Charles C. Berry
Issues like that in this thread can often be resolved by reading the help page for the relevant function. From: ?wilcox.test Note The literature is not unanimous about the definitions of the Wilcoxon rank sum and Mann-Whitney tests. The two most common definitions correspond to the sum

Re: [R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-08-20 Thread Cedric Laczny
Hi Chloe, first of all, I want to note, that you should be careful using the WMW-test. Even though it is often reported to be some sort of a "swiss-army-knife" for comparing two distributions, recent research on this test has revelaed that it is crucial what hypotheses you consider. Also the as

[R] U value from wilcox.test

2010-08-20 Thread Chloe
Dear all, I want to compare the efficiency of 2 methods in extracting proteins from algal samples. I collected 6 independant algal samples and I extracted 3 by the method 1 and 3 others by the method 2. So I have 2 groups of 3 samples, that are not paired. I would like to know if the results obta