Re: [R] median by geometric mean -- are we missing what's important?

2011-01-18 Thread Keith Jewell
Yes, of course. I think all the posts up to Bert's addressed the coding question as asked - how to calculate a particular version of the median (not the mean) rather than any underlying, unstated, statistical or scientific question. IIRC there hasn't been any indication that non-positive values

Re: [R] median by geometric mean -- are we missing what's important?

2011-01-17 Thread Joshua Wiley
On Mon, Jan 17, 2011 at 9:23 AM, Bert Gunter wrote: > Folks: > > I know this may be overreaching, but are we missing what's important? > WHY do the zeros occur? Are they values less then a known or unknown > LOD? -- and/or is there positive mass on zero? In either case, using > logs to calculate a

Re: [R] median by geometric mean -- are we missing what's important?

2011-01-17 Thread Bert Gunter
Folks: I know this may be overreaching, but are we missing what's important? WHY do the zeros occur? Are they values less then a known or unknown LOD? -- and/or is there positive mass on zero? In either case, using logs to calculate a geometric mean may not make sense. Paraphrasing Greg Snow, what