Re: [R-pkg-devel] Is S3 class registration essential for CRAN?

2016-07-13 Thread Henrik Bengtsson
I second Dirk. Also, from my experience: A good rule of thumb is that you should fix all NOTEs (i.e. not have them) when you submit to CRAN. It's only when you have a really good reason you could try to convince CRAN that they are there and that they cannot be fixed easily. I've got 20+

Re: [R-pkg-devel] Is S3 class registration essential for CRAN?

2016-07-12 Thread Dirk Eddelbuettel
On 12 July 2016 at 17:47, S Ellison wrote: | A short question: How necessary is explicit S3 class registration for CRAN submission? | R-forge's check is giving me a note on this for a handful of methods in a package, and I'm unclear whether it is something that _needs_ to be fixed for CRAN

[R-pkg-devel] Is S3 class registration essential for CRAN?

2016-07-12 Thread S Ellison
A short question: How necessary is explicit S3 class registration for CRAN submission? R-forge's check is giving me a note on this for a handful of methods in a package, and I'm unclear whether it is something that _needs_ to be fixed for CRAN submission by registering all S3 methods, needs