On 08/11/2023 16.38, Pol Dellaiera wrote:
you define functions doing I/O as Impure functions.
But without I/O, no build output can be written, so all builds must use
impure functions.
In practice we see non-determinism from approx 10 sources, such as
documented in
On Thu, 2023-11-09 at 22:12 +0100, kpcyrd wrote:
> > - $E$, the set of all possible software environment
>
> I'm not aware of any project having this in scope. It's crucial for
> projects to document their build environment (see buildinfo files) and
> matching it when reproducing the build. If
On 11/9/23 11:13, Pol Dellaiera wrote:
The document includes a dedicated section that attempts to formalize the
concepts of 'computation' and 'reproducibility'. I've taken the liberty
of synthesizing our formalism discussions into an online document, which
is now available at:
Thanks John,
I will read all of this carefully.
In the meantime, and based on all the input I gathered, I have begun drafting a
document which is now available at:
https://typst.app/project/rhUl4XwrXToXvxjoaWB6DI
The idea is to have a more formal approach of the definitions.
Let me know
Thanks Ed,
Based on all the input I gathered, I have begun drafting a document which is
now available at: https://typst.app/project/rhUl4XwrXToXvxjoaWB6DI
Let me know what you think, feel free to made all your comments.
On 11/9/23 02:02, Ed Warnicke wrote:
Pol,
Formal definitions can be
Pol Dellaiera writes:
> Upon reflection, I realize that my initial email may not have fully
> conveyed my objective. My intent is to lay the groundwork for a
> rigorous, formal definition of reproducibility in C.S.
One thing that the official definition
Dear Holger,
Upon reflection, I realize that my initial email may not have fully conveyed my
objective. My intent is to lay the groundwork for a rigorous, formal definition
of reproducibility in C.S.
To this end, I have begun drafting a document that delves into the nuances of
Pol,
Formal definitions can be quite helpful. I suspect your ambitions greatly
exceed my thoughts on the subject, but I thought I might share how I think
about it in the hopes it might prove of some assistance.
A build is reproducible if an equivalent set of inputs into the build
results in an
Pol Dellaiera wrote:
> To that end, I'm currently drafting a formal definition of
> reproducibility that I hope to contribute. However, before I proceed
> further, I would like to know whether any of you have already worked
> on formulating such a definition.
Here are a few emails (from prior
Hi Pol,
On Wed, Nov 08, 2023 at 04:38:19PM +0100, Pol Dellaiera wrote:
> I'm writing to express my enthusiasm for the discussions and initiatives that
> took place during the meeting in Hamburg. Although I was regrettably unable
> to attend, I have been closely following the outcomes and I'm
Dear friends, colleagues,
I'm writing to express my enthusiasm for the discussions and initiatives that
took place during the meeting in Hamburg. Although I was regrettably unable to
attend, I have been closely following the outcomes and I'm particularly
interested in the effort to enhance
11 matches
Mail list logo
