[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-17 Thread Jack K
To reduce "knee jam on sharp turn" issues with bar-end shifters I always trim off a shifter body's worth of handle bar end. For me that helps a lot in keeping from getting poked by the shift lever. I've seen it written that some bars narrow enough away from the tip that a bar-end shift will no

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-17 Thread Joe Bernard
That's good advice. The biggest problem with bar-ends (on drops) is just getting used to where they are and learning to not jam your knees into them on sharp turns. It's such a strong muscle memory for me now that I still do it on my brifter bike! -- You received this message because you are

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-17 Thread Pancake
Mark's suggestion: If your friend is set on STI, then he should go with a complete Shimano > drivetrain. My experience with Shimano STI and the Sugino crank left much > to be desired. It just didn't shift as sure and smooth as a full Shimano > package. All other parts will work fine.

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Jim A
Aeropref mentions front derailleur FD-3030 which is the same series as their shifters and is compatible. The Sora shifters you are writing about are compatible with your rear derailleur but not with your front derailleur (cable actuation ratio was changed). On Tuesday, April 16, 2019 at

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Pancake
Thanks Aeropref, that’s just what I needed to know. Could you tell me which front derailleur you’re using with that setup? -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it,

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread ted
Friction fd shifter on the down tube. I used that with campy ergo for a while and liked it fine. I think I read Mark A. uses a dt front shifter for cross so the bar end doesn’t get in his face during run ups with the bike shouldered. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread aeroperf
I'm running the Sugino 26/36/46 crank with a Sora FD3030 front derailleur on my Sam. The Shimano R3030 and R3000 brifters work fine. I think you'd miss that lower gear if you went to a double. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch"

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Joe Bernard
There's another way you can go that would solve all the issues: Microshift Advent 1x for drops. It's relatively cheap, but you'll need the whole kit: Wide range 9-speed cassette, right brifter and matching left lever, rear derailleur (use current chain). Then you ditch the big and granny rings

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Pancake
I like that idea Jonathan, but my friend says his knees hit the bar ends when they’re in the extended back position (low gear for the front/left, high bear on the rear/right). As I write that it occurs to me that perhaps wider bars are a cheaper and possibly better solution. But the friend is

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Jonathan K.
Another option would be asymmetric shifting. Brifter for the rear, bar end for the front. He'd have indexed for the cassette, which is where most of the shifting happens anyway, and you'd get the trimming and compatibility of friction up front. On Tuesday, April 16, 2019 at 8:48:38 AM UTC-5,

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Joe Bernard
As I said, you might get lucky. Matching 105 brifters to the 105 fd means the shifter-to-derailer action will be correct, so that's a start. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-16 Thread Pancake
Wow, it's wild how they sorted out getting "Shirmego" to work! I'm frustrated that it seems a standard Shimano triple shifter probably won't work with the Sugino XD2 crankset. So the options are: (1) get a shimano crankset without the great low range of a the Sugino XD2 (2) Shirmego that allows

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Kurt Manley
You need to use the alternate cable routing, clamping the cable on the opposite side of the pinch bolt to do Campy 10 to Shimano 9 Here's a nicely written guide that helped me when I set mine up https://www.cxmagazine.com/shimano-campagnolo-ergopower-compatibility On Monday, April 15, 2019 at

Re: [RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Steve Palincsar
Don't you need Campagnolo 11 Ergo to index right with Shimano 9? On 4/15/19 7:27 PM, Kurt Manley wrote: I'd recommend Campy 10 speed shifters set up "Shirmego" style. They will work good with noodles since they are shorter and the front shifter has very good trim adjustment which is needed

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Kurt Manley
I'd recommend Campy 10 speed shifters set up "Shirmego" style. They will work good with noodles since they are shorter and the front shifter has very good trim adjustment which is needed when you're trying to run chainrings that don't match what Shimano designed into their triple setup. I've

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Joe Bernard
The chink in this plan is the cranks. The bike wasn't built to run brifters, and it'll be sheer dumb luck if the front shifting works. You're starting with a 105 derailer which will match Shimano brifters so that's a plus, but it's designed for a specific set of Shimano rings. Good luck! 爛 --

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Pancake
Interesting and good thought - I'll check with him for at least a photo of the bike he used before. It was ridden on a 3 day tour but before that he hadn't been riding at all (and didn't own a bike for many years) but he enjoyed it enough to want a touring sort of steel bike with drop bars ...

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Reid Echols
Were the bars on his last bike that long of a reach (those look like Noodles or similar). In my experience, brifters work much better/are much more comfortable with shorter reach modern bars. The Soma HWY One (and VO clone of it) is one of the only games in town for that in 26.0 and silver.

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread lukeheller
Yeah either will work. I've got a set of used 9speed 105 black shifters if you prefer. I'll sell them for $75 shipped On Monday, April 15, 2019 at 1:42:39 PM UTC-4, Pancake wrote: > > My initial best guess for dual control shifter/brakes are: > > (a) Shimano R3030 and R3000 brifters ($132 for

[RBW] Re: 3x9 brifter recommendations? (Sam Hillborne 62cm, Tektro r559, noodles)

2019-04-15 Thread Pancake
My initial best guess for dual control shifter/brakes are: (a) Shimano R3030 and R3000 brifters ($132 for the set) https://www.bikesale.com/shimanosorar30303x9-speedbrakeshiftleverset.aspx (b) Micronew (Microshift?) R9 controla ($72 for the set): https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07DK73PHH Would these