While cataloging new titles in the Opposing viewpoints series, I came across LCCN 2012044960. This has a 130 Genetic engineering (Merino), which makes sense due to the new way we are dealing with conflicts in RDA (LC-PCC PS for 6.27.1.9). On the other hand, other titles within the series, such as 2013002233 (Dictatorships), 2013002332 (Organ donation), and 2013001147 (Civil liberties) don't include a 130 to break conflicts (yet--all are currently CIP records, so perhaps the 130s will be added when the records are updated with the finished books). If such 130s are indeed needed, I had questions on how to best create them:
For 2013002233, 130 $aDictatorships (Lansford), following the example of 130 Genetic engineering (Merino), seems reasonable. For 2013001147, would Civil liberties (Opposing viewpoints series (Unnumbered)) or Civil liberties (Merino : Opposing viewpoints series (Unnumbered)) be appropriate? (based on a conflict with 2012022607 (Civil liberties, in the series Global viewpoints) in the use of "Civil liberties (Merino)"*) For 2013002332, would Organ donation (Egendorf : 2013) be best*, or can this just be Organ donation (Egendorf)? (in light of 2008053998, which though it has the same title and editor of compilation, should probably be considered a new work since the articles within each chapter differ significantly between the c2009 book and the c2013 version). *the PS at General #4 says "Do not predict a conflict."--is it predicting a conflict if one considers what an AACR2 record's would 130 would be if it were converted to RDA? Thank you for your assistance, Bryan Baldus Senior Cataloger Quality Books Inc. The Best of America's Independent Presses 1-800-323-4241x402 bryan.bal...@quality-books.com
