Re: FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-26 Thread Steve \Stevers!\ Coile
On Thu, 26 Mar 1998, Bradley, Greg wrote: [...] init--which isn't part of the kernel--doesn't exist Here we have a perfect example of an OS asking requiring user input. Huh? When does init ask for user input? How is the "OS" asking for input when dealing with init? [...] Without all of this,

FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-26 Thread Bradley, Greg
For instance, under your definition for the Linux "operating system", the system could not communicate with the network It is not necessary to have a NOS to have an OS. We had stand alone mainframes with OS's before lans were invented. /bin/sh--which isn't a part of the kernel I don't have

FW: FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-26 Thread Bradley, Greg
How? The kernel starts init ( Before we can load the kernel, we need a bootstrap in the bios. Is this part of the operating system as well? Huh? The program, init, is a user input. Put a different program there called init and something different happens, according the the users input, ie the

FW: FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-26 Thread Bradley, Greg
Huh? When does init ask for user input? How is the "OS" asking for input when dealing with init? init INPUTS a SCRIPT file, /etc/init.tab containing instructions FROM THE USER (root) on what to do. Functionally this is the same as dos reading autoexec.bat. If you have a standalone Linux

Re: FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-26 Thread Douglas F. Elznic
On Thu, 26 Mar 1998, Steve "Stevers!" Coile wrote: Huh? When does init ask for user input? How is the "OS" asking for input when dealing with init? Init accepts arguments these are inputs aren't they. I might not understand init very well but I thought that you need to define for init what

FW: How is linux not an O/S Was: Re: Want to give back to linux?

1998-03-25 Thread Bradley, Greg
After you boot the kernel, you can run any number of PROGRAMS to provide the functionality required, getty, bash etc might be useful here. The act of running the program is an acceptance of user input. The kernel manages memory and autoboots, so it handles peripherals. ergo, it is an operating