religion in founding era state constitutions

2006-10-04 Thread Coyle, Dennis
One of our graduate students is beginning a dissertation on the treatment of religion in state constitutions in the founding era, and broader discussions about its importance and problems at the state level during that period. Recommendations of primary and scholarly sources would be appreciat

RE: "Silent Night" controversy

2005-12-14 Thread Coyle, Dennis
This is fascinating. On one hand it shows how we may be too quick to believe stories of secular excesses, and I think the "laughed out of school" subject line was perhaps a spur-of-the-moment comment that might give a misimpression. I think persons of faith should give secularists and their bel

RE: Cutter and the Separation of Church and State

2005-06-01 Thread Coyle, Dennis
In many cases the conservative justices have argued that the Establishment Clause requires neutrality among religious denominations or sects, but not neutrality toward religion in general. If a majority of justices were to endorse this view, no doubt doctrine would shift in a direction more plea

RLUIPA and exceptions to standards of scrutiny

2005-05-31 Thread Coyle, Dennis
Yes, KOREMATSU seems more clearly an outlier case in strict-scrutiny jurisprudence, perhaps better explained by historical and political context than any pretense of jurisprudence. Other than that, back in the "good old days" compellng interest tests rather predictably spelled defeat for the g