RE: Trinity Lutheran and the ERISA cases - Do Churches Want Special Treatment or Not?

2017-04-27 Thread Failinger, Marie
My class discussed this problem of government funding of parochial schools yesterday. Most retreated to the simplistic model of “don’t take the money if you don’t want the conditions,” which isn’t very reflective about the deeper and longer-term issues involved in financial interdependence be

Re: "Necessary," and alternatives that are less restrictive of one right, but that burden other interests

2014-12-22 Thread Failinger, Marie
Eugene, this seems to me to strike at the problem of finding parallels in necessity in the criminal law sense with necessity in the constitutional law LRA sense. In a self-defense or necessity situation, the defendant needs to act on the basis of very incomplete information, i.e., what he can see

Re: Holt v. Hobbs Oral Argument - the comb

2014-10-08 Thread Failinger, Marie
) and budgetary issues (e.g. in claims for kosher or Halal > diets). It seems to me that courts are fairly able to assess budgetary > justifications. However I fear that they are less able to assess > security concerns as they exist on the ground. If the court imposes > truly strict scruti

Re: Holt v. Hobbs Oral Argument

2014-10-07 Thread Failinger, Marie
I haven't read all of the background materials, but it seems to me a little bizarre to worry about what one could hide in a 1/4, 1/2 or even 3 inch beard given what one could hide in a typical prison uniform. If uniforms are searched for contraband, why not beards? Seems like it would be much eas