Re: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Brad M Pardee
Marty, My apologies if you felt the _expression_ I used was in poor taste and inappropriate.  While I view the _expression_ differently, I can understand why a person would view it as you do, and I'll refrain from using it here again. As to the biology text in question, it's certainly appropriate

Re: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Michael MASINTER
Brad's hypothesis would be more convincing if the school's science books also included explanations that various religions posit(ed) a geocentric universe, reject germs and other physical explanations as a cause of disease, and offer supernatural explanations for weather phenomena. The reality is

Re: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Marty Lederman
a scientific perspective, and thus an inadvisable and unfortunate curricular decision.     - Original Message - From: Brad M Pardee To: Law & Religion issues for Law Academics Sent: Monday, November 28, 2005 3:35 PM Subject: Re: RE:creationsim redux Marc, I

Re: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Brad M Pardee
Marc, I think it is a victory (albeit a very small one) for ID supporters because it means a textbook publisher had the nerve to acknowledge that many people do not believe in evolution.  And Americans United is undoubtedly unhappy that not every publisher is drinking the koolaid. Marty, Isn't it

RE: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Marc Stern
, November 28, 2005 3:09 PM To: Law & Religion issues for Law Academics Subject: Re: RE:creationsim redux   Marc:  Might it have something to do with the fact that the statement appears in a biology text, rather than in a comparative religions text, and that therefore the foreseeable -- and, da

Re: RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Marty Lederman
tered throughout this particular biology text . . . but I doubt it. - Original Message - From: Marc Stern To: Law & Religion issues for Law Academics Sent: Monday, November 28, 2005 2:58 PM Subject: RE:creationsim redux        A news s

RE:creationsim redux

2005-11-28 Thread Marc Stern
       A news story from Florida  reports that a text being considered for adoption in the Broward County (Florida)  contains the following sentences:   The high school text, Biology: The Dynamics of Life, says on Page 388: "Many of the world's major religions teach th