RE: The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-16 Thread Newsom Michael
Academics Subject: The quid pro quo theory I've always been puzzled about this quid pro quo theory of the Religion Clauses. There is no religion as a source of values and beliefs; there are *religions* (or denominations) as a source of values and beliefs. Many of them may share many values

RE: The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-16 Thread Lupu
issues for Law Academics Subject: The quid pro quo theory I've always been puzzled about this quid pro quo theory of the Religion Clauses. There is no religion as a source of values and beliefs; there are *religions* (or denominations) as a source of values and beliefs. Many of them may share

RE: The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-16 Thread Sisk, Gregory C.
Religion issues for Law Academics Subject: The quid pro quo theory I've always been puzzled about this quid pro quo theory of the Religion Clauses. There is no religion as a source of values and beliefs; there are *religions* (or denominations) as a source of values and beliefs. Many of them

RE: The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-11 Thread Berg, Thomas C.
theory I've always been puzzled about this quid pro quo theory of the Religion Clauses. There is no religion as a source of values and beliefs; there are *religions* (or denominations) as a source of values and beliefs. Many of them may share many values, but they will also differ on many values

Re: The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-10 Thread Steven Jamar
Sorry, but I don't see any of this as demonstrable or even as really very relevant to the interpretation of or to a consideration of the value of the religion clauses. 1. Free exercise is a valuable thing regardless of a law insuring it which affects various groups differently. The different

The quid pro quo theory

2004-06-09 Thread Volokh, Eugene
I've always been puzzled about this quid pro quo theory of the Religion Clauses. There is no religion as a source of values and beliefs; there are *religions* (or denominations) as a source of values and beliefs. Many of them may share many values, but they will also differ on many values