Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread N. Dragoe
Hi: I am not, in any way, encouraging anyone to send copyrighted data over the net. What I am saying is: -there are people which, for various reasons, do not have access to this (or other) database -it is their right to find all the possible LEGAL ways to access the data they need -if they ask a

Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread Armel Le Bail
>It was started with about 2,000 patterns >contributed by one of those monsters that Armel, among others, loves to >hate: a money making corporation, The Dow Chemical company ICDD is not supposed to make money, nowadays, if one believes the first words at their Web site : >The International C

Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread r. a. young
I wish to make a public statement of thanks Dr. Winburn for his cogent and well targeted comments, (see below) about tapping into data bases that others have paid for. The thrust of his comments applies equally to the ICDD's data base (PDF). A possible slight difference is that not only money b

Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread Dr. Ryan S. Winburn
I don't know...is it worth it? Probably not, but, technically, any way you look at it, giving away the ICSD data over the mailing list IS stealing from the database supplier.(and yes, I know that was a sentence with horrible grammar!) Next thing you know, someone is going to ask for a copy of th

Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread N. Dragoe
Hi: I am not sure about the perspective. My point is: it is worth to pay for 100 000 entries when you need, say, 10 data sets in one year ? - Original Message - From: Dr. Ryan S. Winburn <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Saturday, 11 November 2000 11:13 PM Subject: Re: N

Re: Natrite - Na2 CO3

2000-11-11 Thread Dr. Ryan S. Winburn
Let's put this in perspective. Is stealing $20 from a bank ok because they have thousands of dollars and I only need $20? In essence that is what we are doing when we give ICSD data online. Last time I saw a copy of the ICSD, the database had a copyright on it. It is then illegal to transmit t