RE: Dollase Paper

2014-03-22 Thread Galli Simona
Dear Norberto, to correct for preferred orientation, Toraya and Marumo seem to apply a different correction function than the universally used one proposed by Dollase. See Mineralogical Journal, 1980, 10, P 211-221. They succesfully apply it to a monoclinic case study, but you may verify if

Dollase Paper

2014-03-21 Thread Norberto Masciocchi
Dear Friends, I am facing a problem in quantifying magnetite in a complex natural mixture, using the conventional Rietveld method (in its quantitative analysis approach). Apparently, the octahedral morphology of (difficult to grind) magnetite crystals affects itd diffraction pattern. To my

Re: Dollase Paper

2014-03-21 Thread Jonathan WRIGHT
On 21/03/2014 10:59, Norberto Masciocchi wrote: ... So, the question is: Is there any way do get around this problem (without resorting to spherical hamonics or to grind the specimen in a WC, SiC or BN mill)? High energy X-rays or neutrons in transmission geometry would seem to help? Best,

Re: Dollase Paper

2014-03-21 Thread Reinhard Kleeberg
Norberto, if the magnetite crystals in a natural sample are so big that you can observe their octahedral morphology and this shape really gives rise to any significant PO, than they are also definitely too big for any quantitative XRPD phase analysis. Therefore, reducing the particle size is

Re: Dollase Paper

2014-03-21 Thread Frank Girgsdies
Hi Norberto, just my two cents: If you observe a discrepancy between observed and calculated intensities, then it could also be that the calculated intensities are wrong. Depending on the software you use for the Rietveld refinement, it may happen that the wrong combination of space group

Re: Dollase Paper

2014-03-21 Thread Laurie Aldridge
I am not sure if it is relevant for your case but in my work the reduction of particle size by grinding is important to get adequate accuracy. See the work P. S. Whitfield, L. D. Mitchell, The effects of particle statistics on Rietveld analysis of cement Zeitschrift für Kristallographie