Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] Compilation and Best Of Albums.

2018-10-13 Thread garym
I rip all my CDs and keep them all (digitally and the actual CDs). A compilation album is an album that I want to be complete even if it contains tracks on other CDs. This could be because the CD is a movie soundtrack, a best of, etc. Then again, I'm the type of person that may have the same c

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] Compilation and Best Of Albums.

2018-10-13 Thread RonM
It's hard to see a good reason not to just rip all the separate units separately. As noted, sometimes best-ofs or other compilations have tracks that aren't identical to the originals, usually for worse but sometimes for better. Best to keep them separate. The total amount of additional storage i

Re: [SlimDevices: Ripping] Compilation and Best Of Albums.

2018-10-13 Thread BJW
its funny, b/c just deciding what to rip, or not, is itself a rather subjective decision, and kinda defeats the idea that one can have a perfect system with clear black and white rules you can apply to everything. i have basically just resigned myself to following "what do i feel like keeping at