[rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor)

2012-08-10 Thread Stephen Masters
Hi folks, Given a decision table a bit like this (hopefully the monospaced font lays it out ok!): Account Currency CanTrade 1 EUR Y 1 USD Y 1 IDR Y 1 Otherwise N 2 EUR Y 2 USD Y 2 Otherwise N LHS

Re: [rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor)

2012-08-10 Thread Michael Anstis
Hi Stephen, You've made my afternoon ;) The operation of otherwise is rather dumb. It does not have any understanding of what groups of rows it is meant to limit it's search of values to construct the not in part. As you have discovered, in your case, the Account column has no significance

Re: [rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor)

2012-08-10 Thread Vincent LEGENDRE
:07:54 PM Subject: Re: [rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor) Hi Stephen, You've made my afternoon ;) The operation of otherwise is rather dumb. It does not have any understanding of what groups of rows it is meant to limit it's search of values to construct the not in part. As you have

Re: [rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor)

2012-08-10 Thread Wolfgang Laun
If any of the positive rules for a Trade (account==N, currency==XYZ) were to modify or retract the fact a single low-salience technical rule triggering on the modified or remaining fact would be sufficient to implement an otherwise for everything. Which account and which currency is available from

Re: [rules-users] Web decision tables (Guvnor)

2012-08-10 Thread Stephen Masters
Thanks for the feedback chaps. Wolfgang / Vincent - The real application is evaluating what products (FX swaps, options, forwards, etc) a particular account is permitted to trade with different banks. The example provided was rather simplified, just to demonstrate the workings of a decision