Re: [Samba] Smart card logon

2008-02-17 Thread Asier Baranguán
Andrew Bartlett escribió: with Heimdal clients and OpenSC smart cards to AD. So there's no option to make it "the easy way". Well, we'll wait for Samba4. I would love to work with someone to try and get smart card logins to work with Samba4. I'm not a coder (almost in C), but have the time

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Douglas VanLeuven
Christian McHugh wrote: > Guido Lorenzutti wrote: >> Jeremy Allison wrote: >> >>> >>> If you have a specific issue, ask it. If you have a specific >>> bug, report it. You did none of those things. >>> >> >> Im not a developer, Im a sysadmin and I been using samba for a lot of >> years know.

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Christian McHugh
Guido Lorenzutti wrote: Jeremy Allison wrote: If you have a specific issue, ask it. If you have a specific bug, report it. You did none of those things. Im not a developer, Im a sysadmin and I been using samba for a lot of years know. When I read the post, I wasn't going to answear, '

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Guido Lorenzutti
Jeremy Allison wrote: > On Sun, Feb 17, 2008 at 04:33:37PM -0500, Whit Blauvelt wrote: > >> Gee thanks, Jeremy, for a personal attack rather than addressing any of the >> specifics raised. >> > > You raised no specifics. All you posted was a general whine > "I can't make it work". Well poor

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time?

2008-02-17 Thread Jeremy Allison
On Sun, Feb 17, 2008 at 06:22:42PM -0500, Whit Blauvelt wrote: > Jeremy, > > I think I can see the blind spot at play here: The signal genius of the core > members of the Samba project is in being able to take a poorly-documented, > haphazardly-designed interface - Microsoft's - and nonetheless ma

[Samba] detailed info for "profiles" tool

2008-02-17 Thread Friedrich Strohmaier
Hello all, probably I got things wrong with "profiles" command. It does strange thins which I will describe, when I have more details of what it is intended to do. Does anyone know a link with more details than the man page is providing. Searching for it gives many many hits! Thanks in advance

[Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time?

2008-02-17 Thread Whit Blauvelt
Jeremy, I think I can see the blind spot at play here: The signal genius of the core members of the Samba project is in being able to take a poorly-documented, haphazardly-designed interface - Microsoft's - and nonetheless make something that works with it. Samba's developers, of all the open-sour

Re: [Samba] Smart card logon

2008-02-17 Thread Andrew Bartlett
On Thu, 2008-01-31 at 13:15 +0100, Asier Baranguán wrote: > Douglas E. Engert escribió: > > >>> The OpenSC and many other smart card pam logins only log you into the > >>> the local machine, not the domain. > >> > >> Good to know PAM_KRB5 exists and can log into Samba. > > > > I have not tried t

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Jeremy Allison
On Sun, Feb 17, 2008 at 04:33:37PM -0500, Whit Blauvelt wrote: > Gee thanks, Jeremy, for a personal attack rather than addressing any of the > specifics raised. You raised no specifics. All you posted was a general whine "I can't make it work". Well poor you. You obviously have no concept of the d

[Samba] Re: windows 2008 server support

2008-02-17 Thread Frank Gruman
Neeraj, This is the type of question better directed to the general user community. The developers here try to spend their time focusing on development and design. The user list is a more appropriate list. I have copied that list as well. FYI - If you have not read the Samba documentation yet

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Tim Bates
Whit Blauvelt wrote: I'm looking for somerecognition that the Samba project may have gone astray in the decision to package winbind as part of the main package, given the many specific shortcomings No problems with doing that. I'm pretty sure some of the little tools, scripts and gadgets for ot

Re: [Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread simo
On Sun, 2008-02-17 at 16:33 -0500, Whit Blauvelt wrote: > My ethic has always been: If there's a rock in the path, I remove it so the > next person along doesn't trip over it. If something's clearly not > documented, or not performing according to common sense expectations and a > fair reading of

[Samba] Re: winbind - not ready for prime time

2008-02-17 Thread Whit Blauvelt
Gee thanks, Jeremy, for a personal attack rather than addressing any of the specifics raised. I'm not looking for a flame war. I'm looking for some recognition that the Samba project may have gone astray in the decision to package winbind as part of the main package, given the many specific shortco

Re: [Samba] winbind - not ready for prime time?

2008-02-17 Thread Jeremy Allison
On Sun, Feb 17, 2008 at 11:15:32AM -0500, Whit Blauvelt wrote: > Either I'm getting too old for this work, or it uniquely fails the usability > test. You're getting too old for this work Jeremy. -- To unsubscribe from this list go to the following URL and read the instructions: https://lis

[Samba] winbind - not ready for prime time?

2008-02-17 Thread Whit Blauvelt
What's the consensus? Should winbind even be considered for production use? Looking back through the archives of the Samba lists, there's a lot of doubt about it. Where people have had problems, there are more often than not no solutions given. When I look at the man page in 3.0.28, there are litte

Re: [Samba] Joining Domain Problem only with XP SP2

2008-02-17 Thread Charles Marcus
Rune Tønnesen, on 2/17/2008 8:22 AM, said the following: I've think i found the solution to your problem. what is the name of the workgroup, it's not in your smb.conf? Since the SP2 pc's are in a workgroup with the same name as your domainname they need to be taken out of the that particular wor

Re: [Samba] Joining Domain Problem only with XP SP2

2008-02-17 Thread Rune Tønnesen
Robert skrev: On Saturday 16 February 2008, Doug VanLeuven wrote: Robert wrote: I've having trouble getting XP SP2's to join a domain. Whenever I try to join, at the point I'm asked for a user name and password with permission to join the domain, I enter root and root's password, then g