AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-17 Thread Bob Barton
Hi All I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the operating system on the file server machine. Suggestions, comments and recommendations

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-17 Thread KELEMEN Peter
* Bob Barton (bar...@ualberta.ca) [20090217 09:55]: Bob, > I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes on an > AFS file server and I am wondering which file system I should > use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 > x86_64 as the operating system on the file s

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-18 Thread Faye Gibbins
Bob Barton wrote: Hi All I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the operating system on the file server machine. Suggestions, comments

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-18 Thread Anton Gamel
Hi Bob! On Tue, 17 Feb 2009 09:55:41 -0700 Bob Barton wrote: > I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes > on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file > system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use > Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the operating > system on the

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-18 Thread Michael Mansour
Hi, > Hi Bob! > > On Tue, 17 Feb 2009 09:55:41 -0700 > Bob Barton wrote: > > > I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes > > on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file > > system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use > > Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the op

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Brent L. Bates
Michael Mansour, cut the CRAP/FUD out! I would NOT depend on ext3 if I CARED about what was stored on my disks. I ONLY use ext3 if the data stored is NOT of "very high importance". I use XFS when I DO CARE, so I use it all the time. XFS is the most reliable, dependable, and robust file sys

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Stephan Wiesand
Hi, On Tue, 17 Feb 2009, Bob Barton wrote: Hi All I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the operating system on the file server machi

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Gasser Marc
Hi, we currently have a problem on SL46 with kernel 2.6.9-78.0.13.ELsmp to run a Legato backup on a 4.8 TB AFS partition on Xfs, composed of 4 physical drives by means of LVM. Contemporary there are about 1.9 TB of data to be read, but the backup job always breaks after 1.6 TB. # kernel-2.6.

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Miles O'Neal
Brent L. Bates said... | | Michael Mansour, cut the CRAP/FUD out! I would NOT depend on ext3 if I Let's not get nasty. |CARED about what was stored on my disks. I ONLY use ext3 if the data stored |is NOT of "very high importance". I use XFS when I DO CARE, so I use it all |the time. XFS i

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Bob Barton
I certainly don't want to start any flame wars about choosing between ext3 of XFS. One reason I was thinking of using XFS was because recently when I set up an ext3 system, during the setup a note popped up that an fsck would be forced on the file system after 180 days. Having to take down a cr

RE: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Brunner, Brian T.
-Original Message- From: owner-scientific-linux-us...@listserv.fnal.gov [mailto:owner-scientific-linux-us...@listserv.fnal.gov] On Behalf Of Bob Barton Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2009 3:16 PM To: scientific-linux-us...@fnal.gov Subject: Re: AFS on XFS or ext3? I certainly don't

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Michael Mansour
Hi Brent, > Michael Mansour, cut the CRAP/FUD out! I would NOT depend on Hmm.. > ext3 if I CARED about what was stored on my disks. I ONLY use ext3 > if the data stored is NOT of "very high importance". I use XFS when > I DO CARE, so I use it all the time. XFS is the most reliable, If X

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Michael Mansour
Hi Bob, > I certainly don't want to start any flame wars about choosing > between ext3 of XFS. One reason I was thinking of using XFS was > because recently when I set up an ext3 system, during the setup a > note popped up that an fsck would be forced on the file system after > 180 days. Havin

RE: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Michael Mansour
Hi Brunner, > -Original Message- > From: owner-scientific-linux-us...@listserv.fnal.gov > [mailto:owner-scientific-linux-us...@listserv.fnal.gov] On Behalf Of > Bob Barton Sent: Thursday, February 19, 2009 3:16 PM To: scientific- > linux-us...@fnal.gov Subject: Re: AFS

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-19 Thread Troy Dawson
OK, Enough of this religious file system bashing. If this doesn't stop, people are going to be taken off the list. Michael, you said something that is completely false, and I need to correct what you said. Red Hat = Scientific Linux, so if it's not supported by TUV then it's not supported

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-20 Thread Dr Andrew C Aitchison
On Tue, 17 Feb 2009, Bob Barton wrote: Hi All I am setting up a 2 TB file system to use for AFS volumes on an AFS file server and I am wondering which file system I should use - XFS or ext3. I plan to use Scientific Linux 5.1 or 5.2 x86_64 as the operating system on the file server machine.

Re: AFS on XFS or ext3?

2009-02-20 Thread Brent L. Bates
Michael Mansour when are you going to stop the FUD?? Red Hat doesn't support it because it is developed and maintain by its competition. Dependability, reliability, robustness is NOT a factor, it is pure politics and nothing more. There have been plenty of people complaining that XFS isn't