RE: Use of URIs rather than enums in C++ library

2005-07-05 Thread Scott Cantor
> I'm afraid that we are going to have the same discussin with java > library(and bigger). Really? I thought the Java library already used URIs. I'm using them now... > Perhaps it is time to decide a little policy for this thing. I'd like > Scott recomendation... > What othe people think? My mai

RE: Use of URIs rather than enums in C++ library

2005-07-05 Thread Jesse Pelton
> -Original Message- > From: Berin Lautenbach [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Tuesday, July 05, 2005 5:42 AM > To: security-dev@xml.apache.org > Subject: Re: Use of URIs rather than enums in C++ library > > I was thinking something similar, but maybe wait until a 2.0 release > before r

Re: Use of URIs rather than enums in C++ library

2005-07-05 Thread Berin Lautenbach
Scott Cantor wrote: But does anyone feel they (the enum based creation calls) should be left in-perpetuity? (They won't be removed quickly, but they will eventually disappear.) I'd expect them to be deprecated for one major release (1.3?) and then potentially dropped afterward. I was think

Re: Use of URIs rather than enums in C++ library

2005-07-05 Thread Raul Benito
I'm afraid that we are going to have the same discussin with java library(and bigger). Perhaps it is time to decide a little policy for this thing. I'd like Scott recomendation... What othe people think? On 7/4/05, Scott Cantor <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > But does anyone feel they (the enum b

Re: Enveloped suggestions

2005-07-05 Thread Heiner Westphal
Heiner Westphal wrote: ... (ever tried to RSA-sign with an DSA-pubkey?). ... Stop, no! I did not even try to sign anything using a pubkey (would be pretty pointless, anyone can, but only one could check the sig, hehe). But I tried to do an SHA-1/RSA signature using an DSA keypair, which did no

Re: Enveloped suggestions

2005-07-05 Thread Heiner Westphal
Hi Martin! See my comments inline. Martin Ravell wrote: Hi Heiner, Thanks for the response. I've been giving this a little thought as I get up to speed with the whole xmldsig thing and pretty much reached the same conclusion. Fortunately my specific application pretty much has control over