Re: listserv processors in 2.2.0a8

2003-07-14 Thread Tetsuya Kitahata
Hello, > There is also a James based list server from Japan that has been offered, it > seems to the project. I don't know if Mark has looked at it. One problem > is that the docs are all in Japanese, and no one seems to know how it > compares, or what it offers. Yes, i proposed the MLMS (mail

RE: listserv processors in 2.2.0a8

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> I've been skimming through the listserv processors code (AvalonListserv, > JDBCListserv, & CommandListservProcessor) Completely different beasts. AvalonListserv & Co are the old list server. CommandListserv represents a new list server. JDBCListserv is a somewhat misleading orphan, as far as I

RE: result from sending mail

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> You're right, I missed the "james-is-your-agent" model; instead, I was > thinking of the JavaMail model where I get a status code upon each send. You may have also missed the fact that messages inserted into the spool go through the pipeline, and can still be processed by other mailets. If your

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> Nothing shows up in the logs in terms of exceptions. The only thing I > do see is a stop() from james when the disconnect happens, but I > haven't been able to figure out what is generating it. There is only one way to get a stop() in the log. POP3Handler.parseCommand has to return false. The

RE: mailet service & destroy

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> Can I assume that in a mailet lifecycle, service() and destroy() > are mutually exclusive? I believe that the answer is no. There is no check in JamesSpoolManager.dispose to ensure that all processors are quiescent before disposing of them. And there is no support in LinearProcessor.dispose()

RE: Out going AUTH

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Danny wrote: > No I was merely observing that AUTH seems designed to identify people > who may be permitted, not machines. Actually, I was re-reading http://james.apache.org/rfclist/smtp/rfc2554.txt. It can be used to authenticate one SMTP server to another. Then the sending server can use: M

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> What would you recommend doing to test the cause of the connection > close? As I mentioned in another reply, check both the Netscape and James logs. > I'm telnetting from windows XP straight to port 110, its either > James or the telnet client that is closing the connection. I would try from b

mailet service & destroy

2003-07-14 Thread Bosco So
Can I assume that in a mailet lifecycle, service() and destroy() are mutually exclusive? In other words, that destroy() will never be called while service() is being run, and if I'm in destroy() or afterwards, service won't be called. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Re: result from sending mail

2003-07-14 Thread Bosco So
You're right, I missed the "james-is-your-agent" model; instead, I was thinking of the JavaMail model where I get a status code upon each send. With James, I'll just have to be smarter about interpreting bounce messages (ie, VERP). I was hoping for some sort of direct notification mechanism (Ob

Re: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Jay Kraly
Nothing shows up in the logs in terms of exceptions. The only thing I do see is a stop() from james when the disconnect happens, but I haven't been able to figure out what is generating it. I'm leaning towards it being something on the James side since both telnet and netscape stop at the sa

RE: user groups with James

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> What is the the way to begin with? Any "how to" somewhere? http://james.apache.org/mailing_lists_2_1.html > I believe I showl use DB as James Repository, right? That's your call. I do. > How to set up the DB to have "n" mailing lists? Is there an "entity-rel > model" to relate lists to its

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> Since I wrote this email I've been able to narrow down the problem That's always helpful. :-) > Attached is a copy of a telnet session to my James server where > James disconnects after I try to retrieve a message [...] > list > +OK 1 715 > 1 715 > . > retr 1 > +OK Message follows > > > Conne

RE: Out going AUTH

2003-07-14 Thread Danny Angus
> You want a authenticate a SERVER identity, as opposed to a SENDER > identity? No I was merely observing that AUTH seems designed to identify people who may be permitted, not machines. Also that it is possible to associate credentials with outward hosts in javamail therfore it should be straight

Re: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Jay Kraly
What would you recommend doing to test the cause of the connection close? I'm telnetting from windows XP straight to port 110, its either James or the telnet client that is closing the connection. If you want to try I could set up a test user for you on the server and pre-populate a problemat

RE: result from sending mail

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> All of the MailetContext.sendMail(...) methods return void. They just spool mail. There is no status. I think you are missing the architectural view. > When I'm writing a mailet, how can I find out the status of > a piece of mail I just sent? You didn't send it. You inserted it into a spool

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> I just noticed that if you prematurely quit James (I > used ctrl-]) the messages aren't deleted. > Is that a feature? Absolutely a feature! If you don't do a QUIT, messages are not to be deleted. > while doing a more exhaustive telnet test of RETR and DELE of > every message in my inbox, Jame

Re: user groups with James

2003-07-14 Thread Felipe Nascimento
OK. What is the the way to begin with? Any "how to" somewhere? I believe I showl use DB as James Repository, right? How to set up the DB to have "n" mailing lists? Is there an "entity-rel model" to relate lists to its users? Tks Felipe - Original Message - From: "Noel J. Bergman" <[EMA

Re: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Jay Kraly
Since I wrote this email I've been able to narrow down the problem and I believe I've taken netscape out of the equation. Attached is a copy of a telnet session to my James server where James disconnects after I try to retrieve a message: +OK mailhost.perspectivesoftware.com POP3 server (JAMES

RE: listserv processors in 2.2.0a8

2003-07-14 Thread Mark Imel
1. You're correct. CommandListservProcessor doesn't extends from GenericListserv because there was from a design point of view, not much in common between the two. 2. Correct again. I'm not sure what the official James plan is for the MLM, but i wanted to develop and submit a command based MLM,

listserv processors in 2.2.0a8

2003-07-14 Thread Bosco So
I've been skimming through the listserv processors code (AvalonListserv, JDBCListserv, & CommandListservProcessor) to figure whether I can reuse them for building an ASP style MLM. If I can't reuse, I'm trying to figure out what classes to extend and what interfaces to implement. So here are so

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Jay, The only thing that should allow a message to be deleted twice is either a RSET command, or two parallel sessions. I think I looked, and you had the same worker id, so the later would not be the cause. I don't have time to look over Netscape's code. Do any of these look relevent? http://b

result from sending mail

2003-07-14 Thread Bosco So
All of the MailetContext.sendMail(...) methods return void. When I'm writing a mailet, how can I find out the status of a piece of mail I just sent? For a bounce, I can VERP the From: address and catch the bounce in another mailet. How do I find out other errors like: no domain, SMTP server do

Re: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Jay Kraly
I take that back, I just noticed that if you prematurely quit James (I used ctrl-]) the messages aren't deleted. If I then telnet back in I can retr and delete the same messages that I deleted in the first session. Is that a feature? Also, while doing a more exhaustive telnet test of RETR and

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
>>>I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... >>No it doesn't thats an incorrect assumption. >>James can't connect using SMTP AUTH, thats a different thing. > So the entire gateway thing is actually useless... What are you talking about? Gateways are quite useful, and w

RE: Out going AUTH

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
Danny, > Regarding the outgoing use of SMTP AUTH for gateways, > it should be a matter of adding the server and its > credentials to the session You want a authenticate a SERVER identity, as opposed to a SENDER identity? My thought had been that Vincenzo is working on getting Soren's mail attrib

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Noel J. Bergman
> > > Thanks. But how can I specify auth for this gateway? > > Short answer? You don't. > I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... What does one have to do with another? --- Noel - To unsubscr

[ANN] James updated in Out-of-the-Box 2.1 release

2003-07-14 Thread Eric Weidner
James 2.1.3 is included in Out-of-the-Box 2.1, an intelligent distribution of over 100 Open Source projects for Java developers on both Linux and Windows. Major changes since Out-of-the-Box 2.0: * Added Oracle and DB2 integration for JBoss and the sample projects * Semi-automatic database swit

RE: pop3 issue on specific message

2003-07-14 Thread Jay Kraly
Noel, I ran the telnet test and everything worked as expected (I couldn't delete the same message twice). I'm still having problems popping messages from James but don't have any new ideas as to what might be causing it. -J Its true that James doesn't hang, rather it seems to prematurely abo

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Timo Nentwig
The following message was sent by "Danny Angus" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on Mon, 14 Jul 2003 17:14:38 +0100. > use. Some SMTP servers might use AUTH to identify valid users, most use So does my ;-) - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Danny Angus
> -Original Message- > From: Timo Nentwig [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: 14 July 2003 15:50 > To: James Users List > Subject: RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server > > > The following message was sent by "Danny Angus" > <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on Mon, 14 Jul 2003 15:43:09 +0100. > > > > I

RE: Out going AUTH

2003-07-14 Thread Danny Angus
woops meant this for the developers list, sorry. > -Original Message- > From: Danny Angus [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: 14 July 2003 15:47 > To: James Users List > Subject: Out going AUTH > > > Regarding the outgoing use of SMTP AUTH for gateways, I think > this should be > pretty s

RE: fetchpop to leave mails on remote server

2003-07-14 Thread Steve Brewin
All this and much more is in fetchmail, the successor to fetchpop. -- Steve > -Original Message- > From: Martin Woolley [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: 14 July 2003 16:50 > To: James Users List > Subject: Re: fetchpop to leave mails on remote server > > > I agree. This would be a hand

Re: fetchpop to leave mails on remote server

2003-07-14 Thread Martin Woolley
I agree. This would be a handy configurable feature. In fact I got incredibly close to implementing support for it myself! - Original Message - From: "Timo Nentwig" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Monday, July 14, 2003 3:57 PM Subject: fetchpop to leave mails on remote se

Re: fetchpop to leave mails on remote server

2003-07-14 Thread Serge Knystautas
Timo Nentwig wrote: It seems, JAMES is not able to leave mails on the remote host when fetchpop'ing it. This would be very useful for testing... Please log this as a feature request in bugzilla so we can track this. Thanks! -- Serge Knystautas President Lokitech >> software . strategy . design >>

Re: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Serge Knystautas
Timo Nentwig wrote: The following message was sent by "Danny Angus" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on Mon, 14 Jul 2003 15:43:09 +0100. I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... No it doesn't thats an incorrect assumption. James can't connect using SMTP AUTH, thats a different thing

fetchpop to leave mails on remote server

2003-07-14 Thread Timo Nentwig
Hi! It seems, JAMES is not able to leave mails on the remote host when fetchpop'ing it. This would be very useful for testing... Timo - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Timo Nentwig
The following message was sent by "Danny Angus" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on Mon, 14 Jul 2003 15:43:09 +0100. > > I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... > > No it doesn't thats an incorrect assumption. > James can't connect using SMTP AUTH, thats a different thing. So the

Out going AUTH

2003-07-14 Thread Danny Angus
Regarding the outgoing use of SMTP AUTH for gateways, I think this should be pretty simple to add if anyone has the time, it should be a matter of adding the server and its credentials to the session and getting a transport using the URL, which will then use AUTH if credentials are available. d.

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Danny Angus
> I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... No it doesn't thats an incorrect assumption. James can't connect using SMTP AUTH, thats a different thing. d. - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For

RE: pass outgoing mail to relay server

2003-07-14 Thread Timo Nentwig
The following message was sent by "Noel J. Bergman" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> on Sun, 13 Jul 2003 14:35:18 -0400. > > Thanks. But how can I specify auth for this gateway? > > Short answer? You don't. I don't believe that james does only support open-relay gateways... ---

RE: SpamAssassin for JAMES?

2003-07-14 Thread Steve Brewin
> -Original Message- > From: Sheldon Hearn [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: 14 July 2003 11:42 > To: James Users List > Subject: Re: SpamAssassin for JAMES? > > > On (2003/07/13 16:42), Timo Nentwig wrote: > > > SpamAssassin seems to be quite a good spam filter - but it's written > > in PE

RE: SpamAssassin for JAMES?

2003-07-14 Thread Steve Brewin
> Hi! > > SpamAssassin seems to be quite a good Spam filter - but it's > written in PERL. Are there any attempts to port it as a mailet? I don't believe a port would be the right way to go since you would then be splitting the code base between Perl and Java implementations, introducing a maintena

Re: SpamAssassin for JAMES?

2003-07-14 Thread Sheldon Hearn
On (2003/07/13 16:42), Timo Nentwig wrote: > SpamAssassin seems to be quite a good spam filter - but it's written > in PERL. Are there any attempts to port it as a mailet? Mad idea. :-) Better idea would be to write a mailet that implements the client side of the spamd protocol, to talk to the l