Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-09 Thread dean . long
Good question  When we have libgraal, there will still be an option (at least for debugging) to turn it off and use Graal the same way we do now, so it seems like the @requires would need to take that into account once we have libgraal.  Maybe we will need a new "vm.libgraal.enabled" or make "v

Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-08 Thread Chris Plummer
Actually looking at JDK-8207267 a little closer, it looks like it's job is to re-enable tests that have been disabled with @requires !vm.graal.enabled, so it looks like we have two different approaches going in here. Which is preferred? If the preference is to problem list, do we want to undo J

Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-08 Thread Chris Plummer
That  sounds like a better approach to me. thanks, Chris On 8/8/19 4:33 PM, dean.l...@oracle.com wrote: This is the kind of failure that is expected to go away with libgraal. You can add the tests to the Graal-specific problem list (see JDK-8196611) and they should be re-enabled with libgraal

Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-08 Thread dean . long
This is the kind of failure that is expected to go away with libgraal.  You can add the tests to the Graal-specific problem list (see JDK-8196611) and they should be re-enabled with libgraal (see JDK-JDK-8207267). dl On 8/8/19 10:21 AM, Chris Plummer wrote: Hi Daniil, My only objection is a

Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-08 Thread Chris Plummer
Hi Daniil, My only objection is at some point it seems we need to be able to run these tests with graal (and other tests that have been disabled due to graal) because graal might be the only compiler, and we'll lose test coverage without these tests. Currently we have 260 jtreg tests disabled

Re: RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-08 Thread Jean Christophe Beyler
Hi Daniil, Looks good to me, Jc On Wed, Aug 7, 2019 at 3:39 PM Daniil Titov wrote: > Please review the change that fixes the failing tests when running with > Graal. The issue originally > included several vmTestbase/nsk/jdi tests but only 2 of them still fail: > - > vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/VirtualM

RFR: 8195600: [Graal] jdi tests timeouts with Graal because debuggee vm is not resumed

2019-08-07 Thread Daniil Titov
Please review the change that fixes the failing tests when running with Graal. The issue originally included several vmTestbase/nsk/jdi tests but only 2 of them still fail: - vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/VirtualMachine/instanceCounts/instancecounts003/instancecounts003.java - vmTestbase/nsk/jdi/ObjectRef