Re: [sfc-dev] [netvirt-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Sam Hague
On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 5:38 PM, Anil Vishnoi wrote: > Hi Brady, > > Please see inline.. > > On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 12:47 PM, Brady Johnson < > bradyallenjohn...@gmail.com> wrote: > >> >> Anil, >> >> We're talking about 2 different patches here. >> >> I remember patch [0]

Re: [sfc-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Anil Vishnoi
Hi Brady, Please see inline.. On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 12:47 PM, Brady Johnson wrote: > > Anil, > > We're talking about 2 different patches here. > > I remember patch [0] well, and the discussions around it, which you quoted > above. Im not that old yet ;) This patch

Re: [sfc-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Brady Johnson
Anil, We're talking about 2 different patches here. I remember patch [0] well, and the discussions around it, which you quoted above. Im not that old yet ;) This patch is the Neutron Northbound API. I dont remember ever hearing anything about patch [1] though. This patch is the *implementation*

Re: [sfc-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Anil Vishnoi
Hi Brady, Sorry to say, but most of the questions that you asked below is really a surprise to me as well, given that you were well aware of the overall networking-sfc integration work and translation layer work that i was doing and *it was discussed on sfc-dev mailing list. *Even you were

Re: [sfc-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Alexis de Talhouët
Brady, I can’t really say much beside the fact I had to fix an issue, this is why I got to see this and leave comments on the patch, but it was already merged. I can’t give any insight regarding the motivation behind this SFC translator and why it resides in Netvirt rather than in SFC. Anil,

Re: [sfc-dev] stepping down as a committer

2016-10-04 Thread Brady Allen Johnson
David, Thanks for all of your help in the past! I'll take care of this. Regards, Brady On 04/10/16 11:26, Goldberg, David wrote: Hi I would like to step down as a committer in the SFC project, since I am working on other ODL projects, and I won’t have time to help with SFC. Thx,

[sfc-dev] stepping down as a committer

2016-10-04 Thread Goldberg, David
Hi I would like to step down as a committer in the SFC project, since I am working on other ODL projects, and I won't have time to help with SFC. Thx, David ___ sfc-dev mailing list sfc-dev@lists.opendaylight.org

[sfc-dev] Networking SFC convertor in ODL

2016-10-04 Thread Brady Allen Johnson
I just noticed a /*merged*/ Gerrit patch in Netvirt [0] to do the Networking SFC to ODL SFC conversion. I have to say that I was quite surprised to see that this patch was merged without ever consulting the ODL SFC community. I have a few questions regarding this patch: 1. Why is this