- Original Message -
From: Joel M. Halpern j...@joelhalpern.com
To: Randy Bush ra...@psg.com
Cc: sidr@ietf.org
Sent: Wednesday, March 02, 2011 12:25 AM
I think that would help, and it is good enough for me.
Thank you,
Joel
On 3/1/2011 6:07 PM, Randy Bush wrote:
something like
Worded like this, with the emphasis on the consequences, would seem to
include such things as inserting spurious communities, as opposed to
just modifying the AS-Path in an unacceptable way. Is that the
intention?
It is quite a shift from the focus of 10 days ago, which I read as
solely
i could make it something like
3.1 A BGPsec design MUST allow the receiver of an announcement to
detect that one or more ASes have manipulated the AS-Path in an
attempt to lure the receiver into sending traffic to an incorrect
next hop.
in a private email, a friend
Ignorance is Bliss. Bliss (Basic Language for Implementation of System
Software) was a
systems programming language originally for the PDP-10 and DECsystem-20 written
at CMU. K-Oberman
donald.sm...@qwest.com
-Original Message-
From: sidr-boun...@ietf.org
Unfortunately, that change shifts things just enough to miss an
important part of what I was hoping to achieve.
While it is true that we can not know why anyone does anything, the
reason we care about it is that certain kinds of path falsification can
result in traffic being lured to places
While it is true that we can not know why anyone does anything
...
The purpose of the whole exchange was to try to get a motivation into
the picture
a conundrum wrapped in a cabbage leaf. the draft can not meet the
desires of both directions here, and the new version needs to get out.
being
