Re: [SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-02 Thread Andrei Postnikov
On Fri, 2 Feb 2007, Dr. Y. Lin wrote: | BTW: What is the MeshCutoff? I read the manual, and it says: | | MeshCutoff | (real energy): Defines the equivalent plane wave cutoff for the grid. | I thought siesta is not using plane wave basis. Why does the code needs this? | Could somebody point ou

Re: [SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-02 Thread Dr. Y. Lin
On Fri, 2 Feb 2007, Jin Zhang wrote: Your meshcutoff is too low (especially for GGA). Try to increase it to 200 or more until convergence reached. Also, a 0.01 deviation is not that bad. Thanks for the suggestion. I'll increase this in my next simulation. However, I've tested the result vs Me

Re: [SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-02 Thread Jin Zhang
Your meshcutoff is too low (especially for GGA). Try to increase it to 200 or more until convergence reached. Also, a 0.01 deviation is not that bad. Jin Zhang On 2/2/07, Dr. Y. Lin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On Thu, 1 Feb 2007, Oleksandr Voznyy wrote: >> 1) Why is GGA pseudo-potential gives

Re: [SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-01 Thread Dr. Y. Lin
On Thu, 1 Feb 2007, Oleksandr Voznyy wrote: 1) Why is GGA pseudo-potential gives worse result than LDA? What do you mean worse? A well converged calculation (i.e. converged in E cutoff, k-grid, and converged vs pseudo cutoff radii as well) LDA SHOULD give bonds (or lattice constants) 1% smalle

Re: [SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-01 Thread Oleksandr Voznyy
1) Why is GGA pseudo-potential gives worse result than LDA? What do you mean worse? A well converged calculation (i.e. converged in E cutoff, k-grid, and converged vs pseudo cutoff radii as well) LDA SHOULD give bonds (or lattice constants) 1% smaller than expt (while binding energies are stron

[SIESTA-L] Question about LDA and GGA pseudopotential

2007-02-01 Thread Dr. Y. Lin
Dear collegues: I tried to run siesta on a few molecules like methene(CH4), benzene(C6H6) using GGA-PBE as x-correlation and measure the bond lengthes and compare them with experimental data. The pseudo-potential file for C that comes with siesta distribution is LDA. I didn't realize this un