Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Ramakrishnan Sundaram
Udhay Shankar N said the following on 22/07/2007 08:59: And also Eco's _Foucault's Pendulum_, at the risk of offending Rishab. :) I started that book at least 3 times before giving up for good. I managed to read about 50 pages before giving up. Interestingly, Iqbal Masud (the film reviewer)

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Ramakrishnan Sundaram
Udhay Shankar N said the following on 22/07/2007 08:59: Ramakrishnan Sundaram wrote: [ on 12:10 AM 7/22/2007 ] I got rid of the book as soon as I decently could, byt gifting it to Herr Doktor Kelty - on the reasoning that he ought to be immune to its effects by now [1]. Udhay [1]

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Eugen Leitl
On Sun, Jul 22, 2007 at 11:14:18AM +0530, Suresh Ramasubramanian wrote: On 7/22/2007 11:04 AM, Abhishek Hazra wrote: but the interesting thing about Foucault's Pendulum is that it is interleaved with passages of amazing lucidity. Right. Just *what* do you have to smoke in order to make

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Thaths
On 7/21/07, Abhishek Hazra [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: also, section 63 starts with a quote from Heller's Catch 22 And I presume the instances of 'if' sprinkled throughout the book are tributes to Kipling? Thats -- Homer: He has all the money in the world, but there's one thing he can't buy.

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Abhishek Hazra
And I presume the instances of 'if' sprinkled throughout the book are tributes to Kipling? please expand. are you indicating that trying to see significance in the actual source of a quoted text is a meaningless exercise? as meaningless as reading the usage of if as a homage to Kipling? one

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Venkat Mangudi
Abhishek Hazra wrote: And also Eco's _Foucault's Pendulum_, at the risk Could I borrow any of the books mentioned in the didn't get it list in this thread? Very curious now... Venkat

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Thaths
On 7/22/07, Abhishek Hazra [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And I presume the instances of 'if' sprinkled throughout the book are tributes to Kipling? please expand. are you indicating that trying to see significance in the actual source of a quoted text is a meaningless exercise? as meaningless as

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread Abhishek Hazra
it is immaterial how many clever references to other work a book makes, if it is unintelligible to a vast majority of readers or ghastly to read okay. agree with this at a general level. a lifeless recitation of smart references might not make an engaging text. but then again, 'engagement' is a

Re: [silk] Readings on Indian History (and other obscure works)

2007-07-22 Thread shiv sastry
On Monday 23 Jul 2007 8:21 am, Abhishek Hazra wrote: narrative might re-deploy these references in a different way within its own structure. so even though an awareness of the reference might have opened up another level of reading, a lack of it doesn't foreclose engagement. I love this :)