Re: [Sip-implementors] P-CSCF Security functions

2009-04-28 Thread Iñaki Baz Castillo
El Miércoles, 29 de Abril de 2009, Manoj Priyankara [TG] escribió: > Hi All, > > I have seen some equipment vendors have implement security functions > such as DDoS protection in the P-CSCF. According to my understanding > this should be a function of the SBC. Is this a standard thing? Please, whe

[Sip-implementors] P-CSCF Security functions

2009-04-28 Thread Manoj Priyankara [TG]
Hi All, I have seen some equipment vendors have implement security functions such as DDoS protection in the P-CSCF. According to my understanding this should be a function of the SBC. Is this a standard thing? Thanks BR, Manoj ___ Sip-implementors m

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query related to SUBSCRIBE Request

2009-04-28 Thread Manoj Priyankara [TG]
Hi All, I have seen some equipment vendors have implement security functions such as DDoS protection in the P-CSCF. According to my understanding this should be a function of the SBC. Is this a standard thing? Thanks BR, Manoj -Original Message- From: sip-implementors-boun...@lists.cs.

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query related to SUBSCRIBE Request

2009-04-28 Thread Dushyant Dhalia
Paul Kyzivat wrote: Dushyant Dhalia wrote: In 3GPP specs, related to IMS procedure, it's written that P-CSCF sends the SUBSCRIBE request to I-CSCF which in turns finds the address of S-CSCF through Cx query. My question is why can't P-CSCF send the SUBSCRIBE directly to S-CSCF using Service-

Re: [Sip-implementors] billing in sip

2009-04-28 Thread Alex Balashov
My experience has been that Session Timers (periodic reINVITEs to the endpoints mid-call) are a perfectly viable signaling-only solution to the problem of billing discrepancies / ad infinitum CDRs due to lack of media handling. I don't think the people who think you can do billing purely out

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query related to SUBSCRIBE Request

2009-04-28 Thread Paul Kyzivat
Dushyant Dhalia wrote: > In 3GPP specs, related to IMS procedure, it's written that P-CSCF sends > the SUBSCRIBE request to I-CSCF which in turns finds the address of > S-CSCF through Cx query. My question is why can't P-CSCF send the > SUBSCRIBE directly to S-CSCF using Service-Route it recei

Re: [Sip-implementors] billing in sip

2009-04-28 Thread Paul Kyzivat
It seems that usually people who ask about billing assume that something in the signaling path can just generate billing records at start and end of call, or save some data from start of call and generate a CDR when the call ends. But that is naive. If you are only on the signaling path, not th

Re: [Sip-implementors] redirected reinvite to be sent to which address

2009-04-28 Thread Paul Kyzivat
Scott Lawrence wrote: > On Mon, 2009-04-27 at 02:22 +0800, Avasarala Ranjit-A20990 wrote: >> Hi >> >> I do not think a SIP entity can return a 302 response with contact >> containing "mailto:"; because SIP is not a email protocol like SMTP. So I >> feel its an error to receive "mailto: in Contact

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query for SDP Negotiation

2009-04-28 Thread shamik.saha
Hi Vijay, I think that any media specific data should be passed as the fmtp parameter,in a way that the SDP does not have to understand them,and regarding the offer-answer SDP delaing with the fmtp parameters,this is what rfc 3264 says, "The interpretation of fmtp parameters in an offer depen

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query for SDP Negotiation

2009-04-28 Thread shamik.saha
Hi Vijay, you should check whether the same rtpmap value is being used by both the offerer and the answerer for the dynamic payloads,for the dynamic payloads the value should be in the range 96-127,and atleast one codec should overlap among the negotiated codec. the payload type mappings fro

[Sip-implementors] Any usage/implementation of multiple PIDF-LO documents?

2009-04-28 Thread Muthu Arul
[Resending to the correct sip-implementors mailing list] Though the PIDF-LO format allows one to convey multiple alternate locations, I am wondering if there are any implementations using multiple PIDF-LO documents. The following are use cases where I think it may be required to signal multiple lo

[Sip-implementors] Test please ignore

2009-04-28 Thread Muthu Arul
___ Sip-implementors mailing list Sip-implementors@lists.cs.columbia.edu https://lists.cs.columbia.edu/cucslists/listinfo/sip-implementors