Re: [Sip-implementors] Multimedia messaging using MESSAGE method (SIP SIMPLE)

2016-09-14 Thread Dale R. Worley
Paul Kyzivat writes: > Note that you shouldn't be using page mode (MESSAGE) for IM *sessions*. > It is really intended for occasional messages. If you are establishing a > dialog (via INVITE) specifically for text messaging then you are abusing > the mechanism. > > For IM *sessions* (text as we

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Paul Kyzivat
On 9/14/16 12:00 PM, Harrison, Jason, Vodafone UK wrote: Hi Dale and others who have responded, Thanks for the response; the UPDATE does not contain any SDP as it is just for a display update as the call is picked up on another phone What do you mean by "display update"? Are you changing the

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Harrison, Jason, Vodafone UK
Hi Dale and others who have responded, Thanks for the response; the UPDATE does not contain any SDP as it is just for a display update as the call is picked up on another phone As this behaviour is not covered by the RFCs we are between a rock and a hard place, however I can get the customer PB

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Dale R. Worley
When looking at a race condition, it is always worth looking at RFC 5407 ("Example Call Flows of Race Conditions in SIP", often abbreviated to "Race Conditions in SIP" or even "Hasebe" in honor of the author). That is the best collection of carefully analyzed race conditions. I've added to your e

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Paul Kyzivat
On 9/14/16 7:05 AM, Harrison, Jason, Vodafone UK wrote: Hi, I have an issue and I can't identify if the behaviour is wrong: Here is a working call Provider Customer SBCSBC INVITE (SDP offer)--> <--100 Trying <--180 Ringing (SDP answer) PRACK --> <-- 200OK (

Re: [Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Brett Tate
> In the failed call I am being told by the provider > that their SBC sent a BYE because the 200OK for the > INVITE was received before it managed to send the > 200OK for the UPDATE, I have checked the RFCs and > can't find if the customer SBC is breaking any rules > by sending an 200OK for the INV

[Sip-implementors] Query on UAS sending 200 for INVITE before it receives a 200 for an UPDATE it sent

2016-09-14 Thread Harrison, Jason, Vodafone UK
Hi, I have an issue and I can't identify if the behaviour is wrong: Here is a working call Provider Customer SBCSBC INVITE (SDP offer)--> <--100 Trying <--180 Ringing (SDP answer) PRACK --> <-- 200OK (PRACK) <-- UPDATE 200OK UPDATE --> <--200OK (INVITE) ACK -