Re: [Sip-implementors] 200 Ok retransmission

2014-04-28 Thread Aditya Kumar
Thanks Brett. so for 200 OK retranmission we start at t1 and stop at T2 and continue untill we receive 64t1. can you also pl conform how the 18x need to be transmitted (both TCP and UDP with 100rel)? this should be t1, 2t1,4t1?. ___

Re: [Sip-implementors] 200 Ok retransmission

2014-04-21 Thread Aditya Kumar
Thanks Brett for the detail explanation. So retransmission is needed in any transport layer. Related question, how about PRACK-response on TCP? if UA sends PRACK on TCP does not receive 200 OK for prack? should it retransmit? if so what is the Timer On Thursday, April 17, 2014 12:39 PM, Brett

[Sip-implementors] 200 Ok retransmission

2014-04-17 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi All, Can you help me with the clarification? when acting as UAS and we send 200 Ok and dont receive ACK how many times should we reransmit 200 OK? in TCP there are no re transmission so after how much time we send BYE? want to know how is T2 coming to the picture and how are retranmission

[Sip-implementors] Notify and Re-INVITE clarification.

2014-03-09 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, Can you help me with the following questions. 1. If UA is subscribing to MWI (or) reg event..when it receives a immediately NTY with subscription state as : Terminated should the UA re-retry to re-subscribe? As per rfc's/specs in which cases does a UE does not re-try to re-subscribe. (Error

[Sip-implementors] feature-tags in Contact of invite

2014-02-23 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, What is the use of UE keeping feature-tags in Contact Header of INVITE? I see some UEs keeping. feature-tags in contact of REGISTER make sense...not sure about having it in INVITE? also if UE wants why not it use Feature-Caps Header? I see as per rfc only servers use this? -Adi

[Sip-implementors] Cross over message handling in Race condition.

2014-01-16 Thread Aditya Kumar
HI, I have UA1 and UA2 in a call. UA1 and UA2 send BYE at the same time. so, on UA1, when it Receives BYE and BYE already send. should it not send 200 OK for the BYE send? how long should UA1 (or) UA2 keep the state 64T1? ___ Sip-implementors mailing

[Sip-implementors] H-I header in the first Hop?

2014-01-05 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, If a UAC supports History-Info, should it also include that as History-Info: person called ;index:1 (or) will it be added by the Proxies only? rfc 4244 says : UAC may add (page number 12). if it is not added we will never know the original person called right ? so Looks it is mandatory to

[Sip-implementors] ACK timeout

2013-12-29 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, UE Receives INVITE. sends 486 //Any Failure 3xx,4xx,5xx,6xx ACK is lost. what should be the behavior. I mean for how much time should the UE keep the transaction state? or wil do that clean up immediately? ___ Sip-implementors mailing list

[Sip-implementors] changing the Direction Attributes.

2013-11-24 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, Is the following valid. A keeps B on Hold with SDP -inactive. state on both sides offer-answer is inactive. Can A send again offer with SDP as (sendonly)--?. is this valid? if so can you plesae point me the reference/ ___ Sip-implementors mailing

[Sip-implementors] REtry-after header in response

2013-11-15 Thread Aditya Kumar
HI, what is the impact on the user experience on the re-try header? say, I send a INVITE gets a 4xx with Retry-after 1000 seconds. will the device automatically tries that call after 1000 seconds (or) will it inform the user that it is doing a re-try for that Call (or) say if the user is in a

[Sip-implementors] pre condition in conf tag

2013-09-26 Thread Aditya Kumar
Hi, Can any one please explain me about  a=conf:qos remote sendrecv this header in detail. I did not understand that. what is the confirmation for? is it only Target can sent it? why do we need conformation when in the a=curr:qos remote none The target can tell its current state and change if