Re: [Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-07 Thread Dale . Worley
From: Maxim Sobolev <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Yes, this is my best pick at the moment, however, I am little bit unsure as SDP syntax is not part of SIP RFC. Since there doesn't appear to be any more specific response, 400 appears to be the only choice. Dale _

Re: [Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-06 Thread Maxim Sobolev
Neelakantan Balasubramanian wrote: > Looking at RFC 3261, 400 Bad request is a better response. A Reason/Warning > header can be added in the response. > > 21.4.1 400 Bad Request >The request could not be understood due to malformed syntax. The >Reason-Phrase SHOULD identify the syntax

Re: [Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-06 Thread Neelakantan Balasubramanian
plementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP Hello, i would suggest use of 403 Forbidden. 415 is usually sent if UAS doesn't like media-type received in Content-type header 488 is sent for a syntactically correct, but semantically wrong SDP offer. Say a mid-call codec mo

Re: [Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-05 Thread Maxim Sobolev
Harsha. R wrote: > Hello, > i would suggest use of 403 Forbidden. > > 415 is usually sent if UAS doesn't like media-type received in > Content-type header > 488 is sent for a syntactically correct, but semantically wrong SDP > offer. Say a mid-call codec modification that is not acceptable. Hmm

Re: [Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-05 Thread Harsha. R
Hello, i would suggest use of 403 Forbidden. 415 is usually sent if UAS doesn't like media-type received in Content-type header 488 is sent for a syntactically correct, but semantically wrong SDP offer. Say a mid-call codec modification that is not acceptable. Regards Harsha 2008/12/6 Maxim Sob

[Sip-implementors] Proper negative final status code for malformed SDP

2008-12-05 Thread Maxim Sobolev
Hi, I wonder what proper status code UAS should generate for the INVITE that contains clearly malformed SDP. I see several candidates in 3261: - 400 Bad Request - 415 Unsupported Media Type - 488 Not Acceptable Here - 606 Not Acceptable What do people think? Thanks! Regards, -- Maksym Soboly