Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-08 Thread Tony Graziano
On Tue, Feb 8, 2011 at 8:41 AM, pscheep...@epo.org wrote: Not really a solution to the problem IMHO. TCP should work as well. (.and as old SNA and ATM guy I like connections...) Anyhow, I wanted to get to the bottom of this and found the following: (this is all on SipX 4.2.1

Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-08 Thread pscheepens
I think that if Bria is doing everything according to standards when Firewall traversal is on Automatic then SipX should be able to cope with it. BTW: The patch was mine... I will put it in place myself now. Regards, Paul From: Tony Graziano tgrazi...@myitdepartment.net To: Discussion list

Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-07 Thread Tony Graziano
its opening a tls connection (port 5061)? frame 21 (capture b) shows the source port for the invite to come from sipx on port 5061, and i (also) don't understand why it would do that. On Mon, Feb 7, 2011 at 5:34 AM, pscheep...@epo.org wrote: Maybe someone can look at the traces attached. The

Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-07 Thread pscheepens
Sorry, some extra info: 10.1.248.31 is the GW (patton). The Patton doesn't like to use the same port (5060) to 2 different SipX clusters. So I configured it to use port 5061 as source port for my second SipX HA-pair. See part of the Patton config below: context sip-gateway gssipx02

Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-07 Thread pscheepens
Made myself floating again. rport was enabled on Bria by accident. Disabled it and now it seems to be OK again.. Still weird that this happened. rport was invented for UDP, not for TCP, and I cant really find in the RFC http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc3581.html what the behaviour

Re: [sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-07 Thread Tony Graziano
If it matters (or not) but I thought I saw in the 3.2 beta that you could force bria to use udp? Or was that my imagination? Tony Graziano, Manager Telephone: 434.984.8430 Fax: 434.984.8431 Email: tgrazi...@myitdepartment.net LAN/Telephony/Security and Control

[sipx-users] Problems with HA-setup, UDP and TCP ports mixed up, only 50% of calls come through

2011-02-04 Thread pscheepens
For the second time in a looong time I have the problem that only 50% of the calls from a GW to a SIP-phone come through, the other 50% go to voicemail directly. I have an HA setup and the GW is distributing the calls round-robin to the 2 SipX servers that form an HA-cluster. Also calls from